Can A Decent Man Achieve Success In This...
Society & Culture24 mins ago
I own a Staff which is a lovely dog and when I walk him he's alright with most other breeds. He really wants to play and gets on well with bitches but not always other dogs. So when I see other dog owners approaching with their dogs I'll put my dog on the lead. But 8 times out of 10 the other owners doesn't do it. Then their dog runs up to mine and often mine will growl and start snapping after the other dog. If anything serious was to happen I don't think I'm to blame as I had my dog restrained and they didn't, although it was my dog doing the biting
When I'm out walking and someone else has their dog on the lead I will always put mine on the lead too. But why are there so many people who don't respect this common curtesy ? Or am I just talking utter crap here, expecting too much of my fellow dog lovers ?
No best answer has yet been selected by happy_face. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Where I walk my dog we encounter at least 10 - 15 other dogs during the course of a walk. Unless another dog was a particular problem then I wouldn't expect it's owner to put it on a lead. As my dog is not prone to attacking other dogs I will not put him on a lead either when encountering other dogs.
It is down to the owner of a dog to keep it well behaved and under control so if your dog is likely to be a problem then I would say it is up to you to put it on a lead not the other way round. How is another dog/owner to know that yours may be a problem ?
In order for dogs to accept that there are other dogs in the world and that they shouldn't attack them they must become socialised with other dogs from an early age. One of the main ways in which this is done is by meeting and playing with other dogs during walk time. Another good way is to attend obedience classes where your dog can be trained when there are other dogs around.
If a dog is particularily prone to attacking other dogs then it should be trained not to do so. If this can't be done then it should be walked where there are no other dogs around.
hold on there. The behaviour that happy-face is describing....dog running up to another, either means that the owner of their loose dog is a complete numpty or has no control over their off lead dog. At various times I have had my various dogs on a lead for various reasons. minor damage to a tail which had made the tail sore and the dog liable to snap if the tail was touched, muscle injuries which meant the dog was not allowed to run and play as usual and of course being in season (the dog not me)
The other really fun bit is when you arrive in tha car park and some fool has let their dog(s) out of the car while getting their wellies on. Ten to one they will come over to me in my car and circle it barking. My dog in the back goes crazy and I wonder whether to get out of the car and what will happen if I do.
Over comes owner grinning inanely and trying to call the dogs off with no success "They're so exited about their walkies aren't they" or some such tripe.
I also knew one lady who had a rescue dog who was very nervous of other dogs. At the time, he was much happier on the lead and would walk along quite calmly but he was terrified when other dogs ran up to him. On the lead he would grown and snarl, but poor soul, if he was off the lead he would panic and run away
I think that it is a courtesy to have control of your dog when out and to be aware of the fact that there are good reasons for people to exercise their dogs on leads and that being on a lead can make a dog feel less confident and therefore more likely to growl or snap at dogs who come charging up loose.
Part 2
In addition, it just seems to me to be plain common sense that if you see a dog being walked on a lead, ther is a reason why the owner does not wish the dog to freely associate with other dogs and it is plain common sense to keep your own dog under control and to keep your distance
last point..My first dog was a loveable goon who loved every one and would say hello to any dog. At first we let him go say hello till he got bitten twice by other dogs whose owners both said "oh I am sorry he/she has never done that before" so we got wary. It si not only "down to every owner to keep it well behaved" it is also down to every owner to protect their dogs from other dogs whose behaviour they cannot predict. Sad but true
here endeth the rant.
Woofgang I praise you. I could not have said it better myself. Sat here nodding at every point you made. Am so glad I'm not the only one with this opinion. To be truthful I was rather ****** off with the first answer as I thought "Why is it my problem that other people let their dogs run up to mine and then mine might bite it. Atleast I take the precaution of putting mine on the lead and if you let yours run wild...... well then it's your problem"
A previous dog we had, my partner was walking on the lead one day when a Doberman came over. As our dog wasn't at all pleased to see it, it started attacking our dog. So in the end my partner had to lift our dog up above his head (it was a labrador) but it ended up with some injuries which luckily we got the other owner to pay for. But surely that can't be right that you have to be able to lift up your dog to save it.
I have to agree too, and wonder if rinkytink is one of the dog owners that lives near me!! I have only had a dog for 6 months and it amazes me how inconsiderate some people are.
I keep my dog on the lead even when on the field where most local dogs are let off their lead. People should have the common sense to wonder why I've kept him on a lead and think twice about letting their dog come bounding over.
At first it was because we had only just got him as a rescue dog and weren't sure if he'd come back if let off. But one day he got attacked by another dog (not on a lead). He wasn't hurt but now if I see one not on a lead I pick him up off the floor.
If my dogs are off the lead on a footpath within ia park etc. and I see other dogs approaching, I always put them back on the lead. I do this to when young children approach or when people pushing prams or pushchairs pass. I think it is common curtesy. My dogs socialise well, but don't take well to other dogs coming up and sniffing them, etc. when we are out walking and they are on leads. One of my dogs is liable to snap at another dog who rushes up to her when she is walking on a lead. I don't think it is my fault or my dog's fault. If a dog rushes up to mine then they are not in their owner's control.
Likewise, I do not think dogs should be off the lead on public pavements, etc. and hate the fact that some people think it's OK to walk through towns with their dogs off the lead because their dogs are well behaved.
I love to see dogs socialising and playing together, but if a dog is on a lead another dog should be discouraged from approaching it.
In short, I agree 100% with happy-face
and some humans Netty! :o)
I am a dog lover and have never been bitten in 58 years of having them as pets and working in an animal shelter. I have had quite a few cat bites though!! (I still love cats though - I have three, as well as my two dogs)
Dogs are as good as their owners. Dogs usually only bite if frightened or taunted. If a dog has a tendency to bite, then yes, a muzzle should be worn.
Whilst I will agree with the majority that it is just common courtesy and always put my dogs on the lead if I see someone else with their dogs on the lead - there is another point worth considering.
I was once told by a dog trainer, that dogs are often more aggressive when they are on the lead, due to their understanding that they are protecting/guarding/warning their owner if another dog approaches. Must admit one of my dogs always barks or growls at other dogs when she is on the lead, but when she is running free in the field I take her to, she is very friendly with other dogs - which would bear out the belief that being on the lead can make them more wary.
I cannot disagree more with the majority of answers here. If you have a dog that can be a problem with other dogs by merely putting the dog on lead every time you encounter another dog you will always have a problem dog. It is up to you to train you dog not to be a problem - both on the lead and off.
Happy_Face - If your dog is biting other dogs - on or off the lead - then your dog has a problem that should be addressed.
Woolfgang - if my dogs approaches another dog and the owner is clearly not happy with this then I will call him to return to me. Just because a dog is off the lead does not mean he is out of control.
Cassimer - you are talking about encounters with problems dogs. I agree that in this situation it is the fault of the other owner. Their dogs were clearly not well trained.
hugnie21 - by not allowing your dog to socialise your are merely creating problems for yourself. I would also add that if you constantly keep your dog on the lead how can you expect it to learn how to return to you when it is let off ? Chances are he will bolt at the first chance of' freedom' that he gets.
FP - you say "my dogs socialise well but don't take well to other dogs coming up and sniffing them" (when on the lead) - I'm sorry but that is how dogs socialise. If your dogs cannot handle this then they are not well socialised.
All - if you feel the need to put your dog on the lead as another dog approaches - who has a problem with controlling their dog ?
Continued.....
I know that I can allow my dog to approach any other dog (or child for that matter), safe in the knowledge that he will not bite/growl/jump up at it. If the owner of the other dog is not happy with my dog sniffing or attempting to play (things which should be perfectly natural to a dog) then I will call him back to me.
My dog is just over four months old and has been allowed off the lead from his first walk and has been allowed to socialise with any dog or human that is happy to allow it. He is only allowed off the lead once we have entered the park and is always back on the lead when we leave.
Rinkytink now prepares for a barrage of abuse !!
rinkytink - I actually agree with much of what you say - and I think most animal behaviourists would also agree that in essence a dog that has been well socialised, well trained and well looked after will never be a problem when off the lead.
The problem is that not all dogs are well socialised - either due to being rehomed/rescued or having owners who have a different idea about dog training to you and I - or are simply difficult dogs.
When my dogs are running free in the field I know I can trust them absolutely to come back when they are called, and to be friendly and lovely to all other dogs, children, adults, cats etc they encounter. The trouble is I cannot trust other dogs and their owners - so it's more for peace of mind that I put my dogs on the lead if I see another dog on the lead. However, I usually then go and talk to the owners and assure them that my dogs are trustworthy if they want to take their dogs off - and more often than not they will and all the dogs play together - or do the cursory sniff thing and then ignore eachother! Obviously there are the occasions where the owners will not let their dogs off because they cannot be trusted not to be aggressive, and in those situations I am pleased that the owners are responsible enough to keep them on the lead.
However, I do agree that often if a dog is always kept on the lead when around others that it never learns how to be sociable and that's really sad as it is missing out a crucial part of dog interaction behaviour.
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.