ChatterBank2 mins ago
Rubbish Dumped By My Tenant.
16 Answers
I own a small flat in a city 40 miles from where we live. Its in a block of 6 flats. Recently the tenant left after a year, and I decided to sell it. (We need the money to buy a house near my elderly mother, we rent at the moment)
The tenant dumped some large items next to the skip bins. As I don't live in this city I didn't know that the city council won't take large items away. There was a bed and and old office chair. Without me knowing the management company sent me a letter saying I am liable for £130 as they employed a contractor to take the items away.
This was 6 weeks after the tenant had left. They didn't contact me first and ask me to remove the items. I have been every weekend to redecorate and get the flat ready to put up for sale. My agent who managed the tenancy says the bond has been given back and closed and its too late to get the money from tenant. He's effectively wants nothing to do with the whole issue and more or less said its my problem. Also alot of other large items appeared long after the tenant left and they could have been dumped by anyone in the block. It seems I'm being charged for everything to taken away. When I protested to the management company they said 'your tenant has been seen dumping items, you have to pay for their removal'. I'm not rich. This is the only property I own and its only worth about £62,000 less than I paid for it 10 years ago. I only earn £670 a month and find it really hard going financially. I don't claim any benefits. My husband earns a similar amount from his business.
Just wondered if they legally can do this to me?I have the tenants forwarding address, but they are refusing to chase her and say its my responsibility. I pay a yearly management/ground rent of around £850 on the dot every year. Some other flat owners don't pay on time and still owe from previous years. Anyone know where I stand legally?
The tenant dumped some large items next to the skip bins. As I don't live in this city I didn't know that the city council won't take large items away. There was a bed and and old office chair. Without me knowing the management company sent me a letter saying I am liable for £130 as they employed a contractor to take the items away.
This was 6 weeks after the tenant had left. They didn't contact me first and ask me to remove the items. I have been every weekend to redecorate and get the flat ready to put up for sale. My agent who managed the tenancy says the bond has been given back and closed and its too late to get the money from tenant. He's effectively wants nothing to do with the whole issue and more or less said its my problem. Also alot of other large items appeared long after the tenant left and they could have been dumped by anyone in the block. It seems I'm being charged for everything to taken away. When I protested to the management company they said 'your tenant has been seen dumping items, you have to pay for their removal'. I'm not rich. This is the only property I own and its only worth about £62,000 less than I paid for it 10 years ago. I only earn £670 a month and find it really hard going financially. I don't claim any benefits. My husband earns a similar amount from his business.
Just wondered if they legally can do this to me?I have the tenants forwarding address, but they are refusing to chase her and say its my responsibility. I pay a yearly management/ground rent of around £850 on the dot every year. Some other flat owners don't pay on time and still owe from previous years. Anyone know where I stand legally?
Answers
1 to 16 of 16
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by HongKongphooey. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
The tenants forwarding address is no use as they will just deny dumping anything (or at least only the stuff they were seen dumping).
I know it is £130 but you could spend ages sorting this out and get very stressed (and perhaps have extra expense).
I would just pay it (even though it may annoy you to do it)
I know it is £130 but you could spend ages sorting this out and get very stressed (and perhaps have extra expense).
I would just pay it (even though it may annoy you to do it)
Not criticising KH fu
the question is:
am I liable for removal of rubbish of my tenant who has now gone ?
and if it is there - remove it yourself
or if it has gone then pay the fee - £130 is a small skips worth but what the hell
// This is the only property I own and its only worth about £62,000 less than I paid for it 10 years ago.// no it is worth £62k what you have calculated is the capital gain
Make sure when you sell you assing 50% equitable interest to your husband and then both capital gains tax allowance 2 x 10K come into pay and you should be able to escape CGT tax at all
I found mgt agencies as you have done carp carp carp
and manage my houses myself but I do live around the corner
I think you have to bite the bullet and pay
[ oh the legal answer is that your tenants are liable but you know forget it ]
the question is:
am I liable for removal of rubbish of my tenant who has now gone ?
and if it is there - remove it yourself
or if it has gone then pay the fee - £130 is a small skips worth but what the hell
// This is the only property I own and its only worth about £62,000 less than I paid for it 10 years ago.// no it is worth £62k what you have calculated is the capital gain
Make sure when you sell you assing 50% equitable interest to your husband and then both capital gains tax allowance 2 x 10K come into pay and you should be able to escape CGT tax at all
I found mgt agencies as you have done carp carp carp
and manage my houses myself but I do live around the corner
I think you have to bite the bullet and pay
[ oh the legal answer is that your tenants are liable but you know forget it ]
Kh - management fee isnt ground rent - my ground tent is around £25 / y which the freeholder just pockets.
management fee - I have found you pay a management fee to a firm where an adenoidal teenager rings you up and says : XYZ isnt working - what are you donna do about it ? ' which I realised the tenant could easily do himself.
there was also the little matter that the mgt company were charging me £80 for a house visit for a plumber and then seemed to be sending her father .....
I paid a mgt fee of 17% of gross rent inc VAT and it was just money flushed down the drain
management fee - I have found you pay a management fee to a firm where an adenoidal teenager rings you up and says : XYZ isnt working - what are you donna do about it ? ' which I realised the tenant could easily do himself.
there was also the little matter that the mgt company were charging me £80 for a house visit for a plumber and then seemed to be sending her father .....
I paid a mgt fee of 17% of gross rent inc VAT and it was just money flushed down the drain
Thanks, guess I will have to pay it myself, but its stressed me out alot since I got this letter. Incidentally I don't think I will pay any capital gains as paid £64.950 for the flat and it the last one sold last july went for £62500. Even if I get what I paid I'd still have not even touched the £10,000 allowance so no capital gains thank god.
I went thro this with rats and mattresses and meat products scattered around a property. The council wrote to me after seeing my feckless penniless tenants and seeing it was hopeless
So I went in a shot the lot - no I chucked out the tenants, cleared up the property, cleared the mattresses poisoned the rats, at my own cost and got in new tenants.
there are times ( a lot of times actually ) where the legal position which of course the reader will instantly realise I inow all about is NOT the important point
So I went in a shot the lot - no I chucked out the tenants, cleared up the property, cleared the mattresses poisoned the rats, at my own cost and got in new tenants.
there are times ( a lot of times actually ) where the legal position which of course the reader will instantly realise I inow all about is NOT the important point
There are two separate strands to the answer to "Anyone know where I stand legally?". One relates to the management company and the other to the tenant.
Firstly, while your contract with the management company probably allows them to employ contractors on your behalf (and then send you the bill), they must also act in your best interests when doing so. That means, for example, that they can't simply employ someone who charges a fortune for a very simple task; they need to seek the lowest quote.
You've stated that the local council wouldn't take the items away. That doesn't surprise me as most councils won't do it for free. However I've never heard of a council that doesn't offer a paid service for collecting bulky waste items. For example, Sheffield City Council would have charged £40.20 for collecting the bed and the chair:
https:/
Assuming that the relevant council (where the flat is) has similar charges, you've been overcharged by £90.
So I recommend checking the local council's website to find out what they would have charged for the job. (If you can't find the information, tell us which council area it is and I'll see if I can find it). Then tell the management company that you'll only pay that amount, since you're not responsible for their failure to seek the lowest price.
With regard to the former tenant, he is responsible for recompensing you for any losses that you've suffered through his actions. So you can send him a written demand for compensation and, if necessary, take legal action against him to get your money. However, just like you, he can then say "I'm prepared to pay £40, because that should have been the cost of removing the items, but I'm not paying £130 just because you, or your agent, didn't bother to find the lowest price".
Firstly, while your contract with the management company probably allows them to employ contractors on your behalf (and then send you the bill), they must also act in your best interests when doing so. That means, for example, that they can't simply employ someone who charges a fortune for a very simple task; they need to seek the lowest quote.
You've stated that the local council wouldn't take the items away. That doesn't surprise me as most councils won't do it for free. However I've never heard of a council that doesn't offer a paid service for collecting bulky waste items. For example, Sheffield City Council would have charged £40.20 for collecting the bed and the chair:
https:/
Assuming that the relevant council (where the flat is) has similar charges, you've been overcharged by £90.
So I recommend checking the local council's website to find out what they would have charged for the job. (If you can't find the information, tell us which council area it is and I'll see if I can find it). Then tell the management company that you'll only pay that amount, since you're not responsible for their failure to seek the lowest price.
With regard to the former tenant, he is responsible for recompensing you for any losses that you've suffered through his actions. So you can send him a written demand for compensation and, if necessary, take legal action against him to get your money. However, just like you, he can then say "I'm prepared to pay £40, because that should have been the cost of removing the items, but I'm not paying £130 just because you, or your agent, didn't bother to find the lowest price".
Hmmm.
Leeds are odd because, unlike nearly all other councils, they do collect for free but there would have been two problems with trying to using their service:
(a) the contact details have to match the resident of the property ; and
(b) they only collect a maximum of 4 items at a time and a bed counts as 4 items!
https:/
I'd be tempted to give this guy (and/or others like him) a call and, pretending that you're expecting that a tenant might leave some junk in the future, ask him how much he'd charge to run it up to a local recycling centre:
http://
I'm sure that you could easily find a quote of less than £130!
Leeds are odd because, unlike nearly all other councils, they do collect for free but there would have been two problems with trying to using their service:
(a) the contact details have to match the resident of the property ; and
(b) they only collect a maximum of 4 items at a time and a bed counts as 4 items!
https:/
I'd be tempted to give this guy (and/or others like him) a call and, pretending that you're expecting that a tenant might leave some junk in the future, ask him how much he'd charge to run it up to a local recycling centre:
http://
I'm sure that you could easily find a quote of less than £130!
1 to 16 of 16
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.