ChatterBank0 min ago
Dickens's 'Great Expectations'
3 Answers
[Please be careful: question contains plot spoilers!!].
I've just finished reading Charles Dickens's Great Expectations, which is a fantatic book! I know its fictional, but am interested to know, based on the medical knowledge at that time in history, if the injuries sustained by Provis (Magwitch) would have been fatal, if he had been cared for properly: i.e. not in prison? Cheers, MrP.
I've just finished reading Charles Dickens's Great Expectations, which is a fantatic book! I know its fictional, but am interested to know, based on the medical knowledge at that time in history, if the injuries sustained by Provis (Magwitch) would have been fatal, if he had been cared for properly: i.e. not in prison? Cheers, MrP.
Answers
1 to 3 of 3
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by MrPahoehoe. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Can't recall what he died from so i can't spoil the plo! But people in the 19th century often died from stuff we would regard as routine - flu; a bang on the head; broken bones - even toothache. It was an age of no antisepsics and no antibiotics, and with overcrowded slums etc the death rate was much higher.
The wound that Magwitch receives on the top of his head and the water that Magwitch must have swallowed were contributing factors to his decline in health, along with the internal injuries from Compeyson.
In reading, you will note that there must have been some sort of bacterial infection because Pip falls ill shortly after visiting Magwitch. The communication of some bacterial diseases is such that Magwitch's bacterial infection could have been communicated to Pip just by Pip breathing the same air as Magwitch. Pip's sickness was caused by bacterial infection "I had a fever and was avoided, that I suffered greatly, that I often lost my reason, that the time seemed interminable, that I confounded impossible existences with my own identity"
Pip's disease was communicable, as evidenced by the fact that he was "avoided" and left alone so that those who had reason to look in on him would not get sick also. The severity of Pip's fever gives the reader a look at how terrible bacterial infection could be, because Pip says that he "often lost his reason."
The sicknesses of Magwitch and Pip were not without comforting moments, as shown by Pip staying with Magwitch during his sickness, and Joe taking care of Pip during his.
When Pip gets sick, he has Joe to comfort him during his time of need. Pip asks Joe if he has been watching Pip for the duration of Pip's sickness, and Joe replies, "pretty nigh, old chap".
Since we know what happened to Pip in the end, we can conclude that Magwitch may have suffered the same fate.
In reading, you will note that there must have been some sort of bacterial infection because Pip falls ill shortly after visiting Magwitch. The communication of some bacterial diseases is such that Magwitch's bacterial infection could have been communicated to Pip just by Pip breathing the same air as Magwitch. Pip's sickness was caused by bacterial infection "I had a fever and was avoided, that I suffered greatly, that I often lost my reason, that the time seemed interminable, that I confounded impossible existences with my own identity"
Pip's disease was communicable, as evidenced by the fact that he was "avoided" and left alone so that those who had reason to look in on him would not get sick also. The severity of Pip's fever gives the reader a look at how terrible bacterial infection could be, because Pip says that he "often lost his reason."
The sicknesses of Magwitch and Pip were not without comforting moments, as shown by Pip staying with Magwitch during his sickness, and Joe taking care of Pip during his.
When Pip gets sick, he has Joe to comfort him during his time of need. Pip asks Joe if he has been watching Pip for the duration of Pip's sickness, and Joe replies, "pretty nigh, old chap".
Since we know what happened to Pip in the end, we can conclude that Magwitch may have suffered the same fate.
1 to 3 of 3
