Cosmetic query -eye liner

[lynbrown]

Can anyone recommend a nice smooth eye liner that is NOT a pencil that needs to be sharpened from time to time. I dont like the liquid kind either, it has to be a pencil  but possibly one that you wind up like a propelling pencil???

[Lore]

I use Max Factor colour perfection eyeliner - it's retractable but also has a tiny sharpener hidden in the base just incase the nib is a little blunt. :o)  

[PringlesQueen]

I use Clinique Quickliner for eyes - it is a really soft almost kohl liner. It is presented in a wind up pencil shaped container with a sponge/eraser on the opposite end.
At approx �12 a time they are not the cheapest product available, but mine lasts about a year even with using it every day.

[boobesque]

avon do glimmersticks that twist up and are only about �5

[Loraxxx]

loreal does one its good. it got a little sharpener which u can use which pulls out the end! its a good un' x