I would think you have three options, all assuming the sofa is in the list of contents (inventory): 1. Insist that a replacement is provided or else the rent is reduced commensurately (in court this would almost certainly be a very small sum to be reasonable), 2. Insist that the rent is reduced (if you are not after a sofa, ditto) or, 3. declare the landlord in breach of contract which then becomes null and void and you promptly move out. By my reckoning none of these are called for or merited but you should press for the replacement sofa on principle, one of same potential usefulness value. You are entitled to the stated inventory to match the stated rent, but my guess would be that taking legal action would be seen by many/most as particularly litigious if not b-minded. It strikes me as unlikely that the landlord would deliberately leave the sofa in as bait - how many would choose the flat simply because of the sofa ?