What's The Deal With Original Windows?

[kvinto45]

I'm about to renovate my 1900 (no idea what style) home and my original plan was to replace all of the old windows. They're single pane and some of the wood frames are falling apart. I thought I would rather have a more modern window for both better looks and energy efficiency. But everyone seems to want to keep the original windows. Why? What's the big deal?

[davebro3]

Dunno - it goes along with the craving for "high ceilings" & open plan "kitchen/diner/living" rooms.

[barry1010]

Who are 'everyone'? If they don't live with you, ignore them.

If they do, consider a compromise of new similar style wooden frames with double glazing. It can look good and be energy efficient.

[Tilly2]

If it was built in 1900, it's Victorian. (just).

I'm sure you could find suitable windows in a suitable style.

[Tilly2]

Are the current ones sash windows?

[pastafreak]

Depending on period/style/location,  it's often best to renovate sympathetically and try to keep originals or original style where possible​​​​​. This can go a long way in keeping or increasing the value of your home. Done improperly you can knock 1,000s off.

Find out what the style is, look at other homes on your street to see what other owners have done.

[Old_Geezer]

Probably because the traditional one look more suited to the house and fits in with the neighbourhood.  But your house, as long as there are no council restrictions replace as you wish. Consider the result if selling in the future though. If "everyone" wants original style it may limit the offers.

[fbg40]

Some friends of ours moved into a victorian house that had wooden sash windows, they had them replaced with UPVC sash windows - you would have a job to spot the diference.

FBG40

[Buenchico]

This firm would like you to consider secondary glazing (instead of regular double glazing), so they've obviously got a vested interest in producing this content.  However it does go some way towards answering your question, so I reckon that it might still be worth a read:
https://stormwindows.co.uk/why-should-we-look-after-our-historic-windows/

[Hoboku]

The original windows will look better and more authentic than any replacement windows you can buy. You can also match the energy efficiency of modern windows by rehabbing the windows, adding quality storm windows, and proper weatherstripping. And it usually costs much less to rehab than to replace. All that said, there are times when the originals are so far gone that rehabbing may no longer be practical.

I'd encourage you to look in to restoring the originals, either DIY or by contacting a restorer like https://surreysashwindowspecialist.co.uk/ (or even a good, experienced handyman).