ChatterBank1 min ago
Fish and Chips
Answers
No best answer has yet been selected by Beswad. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.I prefer (though I am biased) fish & chips from Edinburgh (or south east Scotland). For 2 reasons-
1. Salt 'n' Sauce not Salt 'n' Vinegar. For the uneducated- the sauce is a remarkably delicious concoction of brown sauce and vinegar (much better than just vinegar)
2. The fish tends to be Haddock- which in my opinion is superior to Cod or Plaice which is what seems to be on offer in London chippies.
I really do think it has to be the North of England, I'm not going to open a can of worms by saying which part (NE, NW Yorkshire etc.) but in my experience coastal towns tend to do the best.
There may be the odd southern chippy which is good, but having lived all over the country on the whole fish and chips in the south is pretty awful: soggy batter, skin still kept on the fish (a defininte no-no), mushy peas are a rarity, as are other sauces (gravy, curry sauce etc)
Greedfly - I know what you mean about Whitby. We were invited for a long week-end stay there a few years back & were most unimpressed. Mind you it bucketed down with rain on the Saturday night & we witnessed a young lad being beaten up by some thugs & his head put through a pub window. This may have something to do with the fact that we wouldn't re-visit!
Having said that, there are positive & negative things about most towns in the UK.
I haven't been to Whitby for about five years now. We used to holiday on the North York Moors in a caravan and it was our favourite place in the world. I love Whitby and hope it hasn't changed too much. Thank you Sprogglin, it was the Magpie I was thinking of. I have never experienced fish and chips as that!
Smudge, It's funny isn't it how an impression can be formed during a short stay depending on the weather and experiences. I'm sure we all do it. I went to Venice and hated it. I was sick on one of the boats and so was my son, it was rainy and cold and we couldn't find anything nice to eat. I would never go back - silly, because I'm sure it is beautiful really.
Got to agree with CiderMonkey that the best is offered by the Dolphin Fish Bar in Hastings. Been to loads of Fish & Chips shops in all parts of the country, and quite simply nothing can come anywhere close to the Dolphin.
Everyone should go to Hastings and just try them once. Don't be put off by the size of the place or how it looks, but step inside and be prepared to learn just how good Fish and Chips should be.