Crosswords5 mins ago
Changing Musical Instruments
Please be with me here but I wondered if it is possible to play a piece of music on an instrument it is not written for?
Example could a cello concerto be played on a violin?
I know it will be in a higher range but I just wondered could it be done
I hope music aficionados aren't offend by my question or lack of knowledge
Example could a cello concerto be played on a violin?
I know it will be in a higher range but I just wondered could it be done
I hope music aficionados aren't offend by my question or lack of knowledge
Answers
1 to 18 of 18
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Ric.ror. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
The only limiting factor would be if the instrument you wanted to play the piece on wasn't capable of producing a sufficient range of notes to cover the original.
But even then you could adapt the music by switching registers.
Obviously you couldn't play chords from a piano or guitar piece on a trumpet or clarinet but tunes are playable on virtually any instrument.
But even then you could adapt the music by switching registers.
Obviously you couldn't play chords from a piano or guitar piece on a trumpet or clarinet but tunes are playable on virtually any instrument.
There are some techniques best suited to certain instruments
eg you can slide notes on a string instrument; not so easy on a keyboard or a horn - unless it's a trombone.
Likewise, i think the piano prodigies wrote music very difficult to physically replicate on other instruments; for one thing on a keyboard one hand can be playing in a low octave simultaneous with the other at the high end
eg you can slide notes on a string instrument; not so easy on a keyboard or a horn - unless it's a trombone.
Likewise, i think the piano prodigies wrote music very difficult to physically replicate on other instruments; for one thing on a keyboard one hand can be playing in a low octave simultaneous with the other at the high end
There is no such thing as a duff question - there are things you know, and things you don't know - and that's it.
I am sure plenty of Bach's works have been transposed for other instruments - organ pieces for orchestras and so on.
As advised, there are some limitations - but if you have personal abilities in this area, give it a try, you'll soon know if it's doable or not.
I am sure plenty of Bach's works have been transposed for other instruments - organ pieces for orchestras and so on.
As advised, there are some limitations - but if you have personal abilities in this area, give it a try, you'll soon know if it's doable or not.
It's true about the Bach Andy - though requiring an entire orchestra to replicate one keyboard instrument rather proves the point
And Mrs Zeuhl (who is a classically trained pianist) informs me that Bach's pieces are relatively simplistic in structure compared with the likes of Beethoven or Rachmaninov probably because of the mechanical crudity and limitations of the instruments he had available. The artistry with Bach is in how the pianist interprets and plays the piece as a whole.
And Mrs Zeuhl (who is a classically trained pianist) informs me that Bach's pieces are relatively simplistic in structure compared with the likes of Beethoven or Rachmaninov probably because of the mechanical crudity and limitations of the instruments he had available. The artistry with Bach is in how the pianist interprets and plays the piece as a whole.
1 to 18 of 18
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.