If you asked for the renewal to be like for like, this would mean they would quote on the main covers like for like, so if you have buildings �150k, contents �40k, they would quote for exactly the same. Covers like freezer contents are usually additional features and vary very much from insurer to insurer. The broker wouldn't trawl through the features of your previous policy as there are too many such as pedal cycles, alternative accomodation, loss of keys, trace and access etc etc. To summarise if you asked for like for like they would take this as meaning the main covers so buildings and contents, NOT the extra features and benefits, unless you specifically asked for freezer contents, in which case the broker should identify this in your 'demands and needs' statement, and then should have made sure it was covered in your renewal.