Donate SIGN UP

cost to replace items damaged when knocked off bike

Avatar Image
CiderMonkey | 15:44 Wed 28th Mar 2007 | Law
3 Answers
my bf knocked someone off his bike on a road he ought to have given way on a while back. The man was fine, the police were called but they were satified that neither party wanted to take further action. it was not at speed and the man was uninjured. They swapped details
My bf now has a letter from the man saying he has decided to replace his glasses and bike which were damaged in the accident. he asked if my bf would like to contribute towards the cost and if so he should confirm this and the man will send further details.
Is this usually the way things work? Should my bf expect to pay a certain percentage of the cost of replacement?
any advice?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 3 of 3rss feed

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by CiderMonkey. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
The usual procedure is that the cost is borne by the person who was at fault in the accident, so at first glance it seems reasonable for the cyclist to ask for the money. As the police did not become involved, a lot of evidence is not available which may have shown the cyclist to be partly at fault in some way. My rather suspicious mind wonders how the man was uninjured if his glasses have to be replaced, and how his cycle needs to be replaced after what seems to have been a minor incident. I appreciate that the glasses may have flown off leaving him with no injuries. Has the man decided to have a new cycle, and then thought of your boyfriend as a likely source of finance? How long after the incident has the need for a new cycle become apparent. How long has he managed with glasses that need replacement? If this matter became a claim, it would rest largely on whether the amount of claim is reasonable and what proportion of the blame rests with your boyfriend. I suggest he approaches the question in that light. If there is no agreement, it is open to the cyclist to make a claim, which I would have thought unlikely. What he must not do is to agree to pay the money before he knows how much he is agreeing to. He could decide to offer a fixed amount.
Question Author
My boyfriend knows that it is his fault, he did not totally stop at the give way, but slowed.

I too, was wondering if this might not be a way to replace the bike (awful suspicious mind). It has been 5 weeks since the incident.
If the guy did not want to take further action at the time thats the end of the matter. It was reported to the police. Let the bike rider claim on his own accident insurance if he has any.

1 to 3 of 3rss feed

Do you know the answer?

cost to replace items damaged when knocked off bike

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.