Sophie on X Factor

[Prudie]

Did anyone just hear her rendition of Living on a Prayer? I thought it was appalling, she didn't have anywhere near the voice to carry it off yet all the judges thought it was great. I must have a hearing disorder.

[bobbie22]

I totally agree with you Prudie. She screamed, not sung the song. The programme is getting on my nerves, and I am going to switch over to casualty in a minute.

[pastafreak]

I agree also...her voice isn't powerful enough for it.

[stokemaveric]

it should have been ''rock week'' but they turned all the rock songs into ballads which is still within the ''comfort zone'' of the contestants...they turned decent rock songs into ''soft rock ballads''...not good...

[erin-x]

Exactly Stoke... I only tuned in again cos it was supposed to be rock week. Seems I was mistaken...... :|

[Prudie]

I really don't know why I watch it, very weak this year (I do like Janet I suppose) and as for that Frankie, well words fail me.

[murraymints]

thought most of them were awful...DO like Johnny though....

[lozzer50]

tonight was appalling apart from jonny i thought his song choice was spot on. the judges were awful, chucking their toys out f their prams!!! bet simn will have something to say about it!

[trt]

I think its past its sell by date.

None of the contestants this year will have a future in the recording industry like most of them in the past, but they will have silly young girls making them celebs for no apparent reason except they have appeared on the telly like the sad lot from big brother and other reality program's!!!!!

[trt]

.

[Prudie]

Yes trt, past its prime. I think it's a combination of weak acts, overhyped antics off-stage and the voting fiascos of previous years. Although I admire Simon Cowell I don't put the drop in viewing figures down to his absence, I think Gary Barlow is the best thing about the current show!