News0 min ago
Listener 4189, 8 by 13
90 Answers
Best of luck with this one, everybody. I nearly quit with it being a carte blanche (sort of - at least we have word lengths) with indeterminate numbers of letters to be removed from clues, clashing letters and mysterious curves in the grid AND (dammit) yet another hunt the missing words game made extra tricky by having to guess the setter's name.
I'm still puzzled by that last bit: "extended sequence" is open to all sorts of interpretations and, while I have the theme, I'm inclined to think I may not know when I've reached the answer the setter intends for entry under the grid. You know how cheesed off I can get with that!
Up to there, a (just about) fair challenge and a tidy enough construction, so as far as that goes, thanks setter, you know who you are even if I don't!
I'm still puzzled by that last bit: "extended sequence" is open to all sorts of interpretations and, while I have the theme, I'm inclined to think I may not know when I've reached the answer the setter intends for entry under the grid. You know how cheesed off I can get with that!
Up to there, a (just about) fair challenge and a tidy enough construction, so as far as that goes, thanks setter, you know who you are even if I don't!
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Zabadak. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.What, no Friday posts! Very slow start. I have found out who you are after having a night to sleep on it, and thanks very much for a very good work out. I was unsure about the variable lengths of letters to take out at first. Lots of PDMs. As usual, I was won over in the end. I don't know how accurate that curved line has to be?
I made it to the end, at last...Obviously one of the harder ones of recent times. Nice puzzle, 13!
I agree with Coalminers advice re the BRB - at least one clue is unfair to 'newcomers'. And I would think that any curve that goes thru the 9 letters in the right way would be considered accurate enough.
I agree with Coalminers advice re the BRB - at least one clue is unfair to 'newcomers'. And I would think that any curve that goes thru the 9 letters in the right way would be considered accurate enough.
Aldanna you have a touching faith in my stamina. Well I've got another 5 but it's the clashes which throw me - haven't got any of them yet. Zabadak, are you giving away more than you should? There's nothing in the preamble about a deleted letters column, or do you not mean column in the normal crossword sense?
Bobbycollins et al, we shared your view initially but it is not as bad as it looks. Given the symmetry, the break between across and down clues is obvious - don't think that gives away anything to this audience - and it is just a question of plugging away and solving clues. One then speculates, given word lengths, as to which answers fit where in the grid and you should eventually get on to a roll.