Worst Ever Portrayal

[ferlew]

For me.... Jeremy Brett as Sherlock, and Geraldine McKewan as Miss Marple.
Both seem to "simper" a lot.

[pastafreak]

Oh...I used to quite enjoy Jeremy Brett...but I've not seen any others except for Basil Rathbone

[bibblebub]

only seen a few episodes of the Brett version (which seem ok) but my favourite is Clive Merrison in the BBC radio adaptions

[Ric.ror]

There was a christmas special on BBC about 5 years ago that was very good

[bundleone]

I like miss Marple but prefer Julia Mcenzie.

[islasmum]

My favourite Miss Marple was Joan Higson, when the series was still titled Miss Marple! I believe that Agatha Christie must have had her in mind when she wrote those books, as she was perfect for the role.

[redman41]

Is Benedict Cumberbatch any better as Sherlock Holmes ?? Not been watching it so cannot comment

[berniecuddles]

only one Sherlock for me Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce as Dr Watson

[hc4361]

Jeremy Brett IS Sherlock to me and Joan Hickson is Miss Marple.
Anyone else is just pretending.

[China Doll]

The portrayal of Emma by Gwenth Paltrow (sp?) I found absolutely dire.

[andy-hughes]

I loved JB as Sherlock - all the flamboyant gestures and rapid movements added to the eccentricity of the character.

[bhg481]

I agree absolutely with hc4361.