X Factor Judges

[Lynsy1]

Which X Factor Judge do you like best?
Choices:
Simon Cowell,
Louis Walsh,
Sharon Osbourne,
Dani Minouge,
Cheryl Cole,

Can't wait to see who you pick :)
:)
x

[andy-hughes]

As long as you don't hold back Elvis!

As a judge, it has to be Simon, who is as close to a 'real audition' judge as the show gets, allowing for its format as entertainment.

As Simon says - a lot of contestants in a formal audirtion process would not even get to sing - they would be sent off as soon as they walk on because they look wrong - being a pop star is as much about presentation asi it is about the song.

Simon says it how it is - which any budding pop star needs to hear - and get used to if they are going to progress at all. If I was able to get the opinion of the MD of BMG Records for free - I'd listen. If you are any good, SC is interested, because he needs to find new talent, if you can't sing, do something else. A dream is no substitute for ability.

I like Cheryl because she is human enough to sympethise with the emotional ones, and feisty enough to bite back if she gets any sarcastic comments - witness -

Contestant tro Cheryl - "Hat do you know about it?

Cheryl (instant response) - "Eighteen Top Ten singles, thats what I know about it!)

And she's got dimples ...

And fabulous legs ...

And a Geordie accent ...

Sorry, I'm going off the point aren't I?

I'll stop now.

And those eyes ....

[Tizzi24]

I agree with everything Andy says - Simon is the best judge, totally honest and if contestants can't take the criticism, then they shouldn't be in the competition anyway.

Cheryl sympathises with some contestants, but won't take any nonsense from Simon. Can't comment on the dimples and legs however, andy!! The other two judges are a waste of space.

[zzxxee]

i like dani minouge she has been in the industry since she was a child and doesnt follow what simon says like cheryl louis alsh would be my next fav

[zzxxee]

*walsh

[LoftyLottie]

I only watch it to look at Simon! The eyes and the smile - and he has brains. Full of himself, but totally charismatic. Who needs the others?

[mosesg]

Definately Danni, Simon is quite good as well but he flirts 2 much with the good looking women to be professional. Loius is only interested if they are abunch of young boys in a band or irish and Cheryl only got where she is today down to being voted for in a reality show, she can't sing toffee.

[ELVIS68]

She can`t sing for toffee but she loves eating it!