x factor!!!!

[mullein3]

did anyone see when simon cowell said to louie ..that girls aloud had said in the press that their was no talent on x factor..louie looked really embarassed..to be honest apart from nadine in girls aloud none of the others are exactly wonderfull singers..nadine carrys them all...their are a few good singers on x factor this year...brenda..maria..andy..shane..journey south..and they are equal to girls aloud in talent..anyone agree or disagree?

[the>one]

totally agree.......and this years winner will deffo come from the oldies section.......brenda, maria or andy.....at first i tipped andy but now i'm swaying towards maria.....no i'll stick with andy......

[sunflower68]

Didn't they all get picked from a similar show though? I know it's going back a few years but I thought they would have all had to stand up and be judged, week in week out, to get into Girls Aloud. I don't remember anyone standing out as not being able to sing in their x factor show. Perhaps they are not quite as soulful as , say, Brenda but they must all be able to sing.

[Robinia]

I can't be doing with Girls Aloud or any girl group for that matter - they're all the same to me.

I've liked Journey South best all along & last nights song I thought was just lovely. The thing is they're probably not what the young 'uns will vote for but I hope they'll go on to do well.

[mullein3]

sunflower they did all stand up and get judged and they were the best of the entrys..but nadine stood out thats why..she allways sings the leads..they will get their hands rapped for saying their is no talent on the x factor as its very embarassing for louie..i think maria will win with andy in second and journey south in third..i can honestly say allthough i watch it their is no one on their that i would buy their cds when they come out..i much prefer american idol..and have bought all fantasias and ruben studdards cds ..."they were past winners of american idol"..

[sunflower68]

I've heard that too mullein3. I never caught the American one. The only one I really rate over here is Will Young - he at least is doing something different, not just being like any old Karaeoke (sp?) singer. That's what a lot of them seem like to me. I agree with your top 3 btw.

[EssJay1]

I'm hoping the final will be between Andy and Journey South, with the Middlesborough lads winning. Would buy both their cds, but can't see that Brenda's energy would transfer to a recording studio. Don't get Maria - thought she murdered James Blunt's song. Glad Nicholas has gone.

[BIRD]

EssJay1 I think you'll find that it was Chenai that was sent home last night!

[twiglet4frog]

leave kimberly (girls aloud) alone!!!!

[EssJay1]

Sorry - I knew that!!!

Tactical voting to keep stronger ones safe