I've gone for What's The Story as the reviews are good and Led Zepellin 4. I checked all my orders over the last 3 years and I definitely haven't bought those before.
I did buy him a rare limited edition Rolling Stones vinyl compilation from a market in the Jewish Quarter in Krakow. I'd forgotten all about that.
I'm with Margo's son on this one. Definitely Maybe is just oozing with energy and angst, like a 90's Clash, Morning Glory is more polished, better production, but despite the familiarity of the songs (Wonderwall, Don't Look Back In Anger, Some Might Say) it's not half the album of it's predecessor.