Although she was found guilty of “gerrymandering”, Gromit, Lady Porter did not “ship a load of poor people out of her borough” as is being attempted by Newham council. What she did was to allow council properties to remain empty (and ultimately be sold for commercial development) rather than re-let them. This, of course had the effect of reducing the number of likely Labour voters in the marginal wards involved, but nobody was “shipped out”.
The issue of Housing Benefit must be addressed. I saw a snippet on the BBC News tonight and some tenants in Westminster were interviewed. They said that they would no longer be able to live in the area (because the maximum amount of HB had been lowered) and they would have to move elsewhere. Well here’s some news for them. I, like many others, cannot afford to live in Westminster. My wife and I have worked in reasonably well paid professions all our lives, but, unsurprisingly, we could not afford to live in what must be among the most expensive areas of Europe. And nor do we expect to be able to do so.
The HB caps are currently £1,083 per month for a one bedroom property, £1,257 for two beds, £1,473 for three beds and £1,733 for four beds. This is between £13,000 and £20,700 per annum. Assuming somebody in a four bedroom property needs at least another £10k to live on, to take home £31k a person has to earn around £43k and would actually be a higher rate taxpayer. People earning less than this would have no chance of living in such an area so why should somebody earning nothing and living entirely on benefits be afforded the privilege of living in a place like Westminster?
Rents in Newham are on the increase because of the Olympic effect. Some of its HB inhabitants were also interviewed today and said they might have to consider moving from the area and shifting their children to poorer schools. Welcome, from those of us in the real world, to them. They will perhaps grow to understand what life is like for people not cushioned by various benefits and who have to cut their cloth according to their means.