Is What Happened On New Years Eve In Cologne Any Different Than What Takes Place Every Weekend In Such Cities As Birmingham?

[anotheoldgit]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3422133/Cologne-style-sex-attacks-happen-weekly-Birmingham-Labour-MP-says-women-baited-heckled-weekend-city-centre.html

These left wing apologists will make every manner of ludicrous comparisons in their bid to flood the UK with migrants.

[-Talbot-]

Posters who are pro immigration are also free to say something constructive, Jack.

Thinly veiled accusations of racism do not count as constructive IMO.

[ABSpareEditor]

Can we get back on topic please, because there's so much off-topic sniping here it would take me so long to remove it all that I might as well just pull the entire thread.

[andy-hughes]

ED - we cross-posted there.

Fair point - I'm as guilty as anyone - back on the topic now, promise.

[anotheoldgit]

ABSpareEditor

Please don't pull the thread Spare Ed, just leave it as an example of how badly a thread can be spoiled from the offset.

Let us hope that we can now all return to legitimate question I first entered?

Perhaps a good start would be for some to respond to what I thought was the best answer?

[Zacs-Master]

AOG, sometimes people completely agree with your BA and don't have anything else to say because it comprises a perfect response. This is the case with me.

[Gavmacp]

Now that's what I call a cull!

[andy-hughes]

I think it was a foolish analogy to make - and does nothing to really assist the argument of or against immigration.

[Gavmacp]

Mr Hughes. You're such a card. I read all your comments before they were removed!

[andy-hughes]

No comment.

[vetuste_ennemi]

I hope JacktheHat returns to the thread and answers my question about the point he thinks Ms. Phillips was trying to make.
Do you know where he's gone, Andy?

[jackthehat]

I'm still here v-e.
I believe that Ms. Phillips was pointing out that similar (but not the same) unwanted behaviour towards women can be witnessed in other cities in the world and used B'ham as an example.

[david small]

That's nice, pulled my comments that were totally innocuous.

[Svejk]

Mine were left, david. Yipee. ;-)

[vetuste_ennemi]

And who has ever denied, or would ever deny something so b*ingly obvious, JacktheHat?
So why did she make she make the remark, do you think?

[jackthehat]

I didn't watch the programme so only have the newspaper reports on which to base my comments.
Someone appears to have asked her a question and she felt her answer was an appropriate response; whether it was or not has be be a decision left up to individual interpretation.

[-Talbot-]

I don't know Birmingham but there can be no comparison with what happened in Cologne. Stupid comments from the woman imo