ChatterBank14 mins ago
Outrageous Sentence!
12 Answers
This was in my hometown, the 14 year old boy stabbed a 56 year old man in the neck and stomach, the victim was the subject of a mistaken identity attack, the 14 year old was given just 4 years in a young offenders institute, his 14 year old accomplice was given a 12 month referral order ............ so much for getting tough on crime and carrying a knife with intent.
What is the matter with our courts system, to me he should've got at least 10 years for just carrying the knife, it does make you wonder what sort of message this sends out and what sort of deterrent this is meant to be, the 14 year old will be out in 2 years, at 16 years of age to get on with his life whilst the poor, innocent victim has to live with it for the rest of his days.
https:/
What is the matter with our courts system, to me he should've got at least 10 years for just carrying the knife, it does make you wonder what sort of message this sends out and what sort of deterrent this is meant to be, the 14 year old will be out in 2 years, at 16 years of age to get on with his life whilst the poor, innocent victim has to live with it for the rest of his days.
https:/
Answers
1 to 12 of 12
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by saintpeter48. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
Sentencing of people under 18 does not follow traditional (adult) sentencing guidelines.
In general terms, people under 18 will only be subject to a custodial sentence if they commit a serious crime. A serious crime is tightly defined for this purpose. As a rough rule of thumb, a young person convicted of such a crime will, in most circumstances, be subject to roughly half the period in custody that an adult would. But this could be less than that - sometimes considerably less - the younger the person is. Periods of "rehabilitation" (i.e. when the offence becomes "spent" under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act) are half those for adults.
Youth's convicted of crimes outside the "serious" category (which includes possession of an offensive weapon) will in almost every instance be subject to a "referral order" (as was youth #2 in this report). There is virtually no other disposal available for such offences.
And please don't shoot the messenger! I happen to think the Youth Justice System in this country is completely unfit for purpose. It is one of the reasons why many Young Offenders go on to become Old Offenders. There are no sanctions of any significance imposed on young miscreants and they grow up believing there are no consequences to their illegal actions.
In general terms, people under 18 will only be subject to a custodial sentence if they commit a serious crime. A serious crime is tightly defined for this purpose. As a rough rule of thumb, a young person convicted of such a crime will, in most circumstances, be subject to roughly half the period in custody that an adult would. But this could be less than that - sometimes considerably less - the younger the person is. Periods of "rehabilitation" (i.e. when the offence becomes "spent" under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act) are half those for adults.
Youth's convicted of crimes outside the "serious" category (which includes possession of an offensive weapon) will in almost every instance be subject to a "referral order" (as was youth #2 in this report). There is virtually no other disposal available for such offences.
And please don't shoot the messenger! I happen to think the Youth Justice System in this country is completely unfit for purpose. It is one of the reasons why many Young Offenders go on to become Old Offenders. There are no sanctions of any significance imposed on young miscreants and they grow up believing there are no consequences to their illegal actions.
1 to 12 of 12
