The Orwellian Absurdity Of Logging Rapists As Female

[naomi24]

//J. K. Rowling of Harry Potter fame has once again ridden valiantly into the gender wars — this time to object to Police Scotland’s policy of recording rapes as being committed by women, should the rapist identify as female. Detective Superintendent Fil Capaldi explained that “Police Scotland requires no evidence or certification as proof of biological sex or gender identity other than a person’s self-declaration.”//

https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/j-k-rowling-on-the-absurdity-of-logging-rapists-as-female/

Following her accurate declaration that only women menstruate, Joanne is once again being tarred by the twittering twits of Twitter as transphobic. Well she would be wouldn’t she?

[nailit]

The attitude of the screws spoke volumes, ridicule etc.
Her/his attitude also spoke volumes,

[nailit]

Of course the screws were 'Real Men'

Personally, real men can accept all as they are..

[Untitled]

“ What you cannot do though is transition to a different sex”

which is why nowadays people tend to use the word transgender rather than transsexual…

and yes i think most of us who enjoy some success in life of we are being honest do owe more to luck than hard work… lots of people work very hard only a few become millionaires.

[Khandro]

nailit; //I got to know him/her really well.
He tried to cut of his penis as a kid.
He/she always knew that he was born into the wrong body.
BTW she knew that she was going to one of the roughest prisons in the country that day and still attended court as a female.
And that takes some doing)//

Did you ever consider that this man have had severe psychological problems instead of trying to analyse something you do not understand? BIID


https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19132621/

[Deskdiary]

Untitled at 9.58pm - sex is immutable. It just is. And no amount of psychobabble BS you spout can change this fact.

Your second point is also wrong. Millionaires are millionaires through bloody hard work in the main.

I actually feel sorry for you for being so demonstrably wrong.

[Mozz71]

//Did you ever consider that this man have had severe psychological problems instead of trying to analyse something you do not understand?//

At least he's trying to understand her, rather than writing her off as psychologically damaged.

[naomi24]

And meanwhile J K Rowling, castigated relentlessly to the point of receiving multiple death threats for simply telling the truth ….. is forgotten.

[Mamyalynne]

I strongly disagree with threatening anyone who has their own viewpoint on things - it's a very lazy and nasty way of trying to close someone down.

None of us see everything the same.

[naomi24]

She is telling the truth. People with penises are not women and people who menstruate are not men. THAT is the truth.

[Untitled]

"is immutable. It just is. And no amount of psychobabble BS you spout can change this fact"

but we weren't arguing about biological sex we were talking about gender... you do know the difference don't you?

"Millionaires are millionaires through bloody hard work in the main. "

lots of people work bloody hard... only a few become millionaires... it is also perfectly possible for someone to be wealthy without even trying... e.g. if they inherit assets, receive generous support from their family, or receive the opportunity to work in a highly-paid field... why not just admit it? it's not a criticism it's just true.

[naomi24]

untitled, what we're actually talking about is J K Rowling being relentlessly vilified for telling the truth... or at least that's what we're supposed to be talking about.

[youngmafbog]

Untitled, did you know black is actually white?

[Untitled]

she isn't telling the truth... it is possible for transgender women to have penises and unfortunately to rape people.

[ladybirder]

At Untitled @14.09 yesterday. I was not laughing I was asking a question. See the ?
Now tell Danny off because he laughed (sorry Danny).

[Khandro]

Confucius he say, rape impossible, woman with skirt up run faster than man with trousers down.

[naomi24]

untitled, wanting it to be so doesn't make it so. J K Rowling IS telling the truth.

[dannyk13]

LB, no problem.

[Untitled]

But she isn't because transgender people do in fact exist.

[naomi24]

She isn't saying they don't exist - simply that men purporting to be women aren't women - and they're not. They never will be. Why can't you understand that?

[ToraToraTora]

PP: "prurient (*) TTT mentions dangly bits - women's breasters I suppose " - where did I mention "dangly bits"? stop trolling trader.