Staying Safe In Manchester.....
ChatterBank1 min ago
St Donald Raped! Rioting Amongst Extreme Rt Tories In Middle England
67 Answers
Donald Trump's family confirmed that a house of the father's had been raided by FBI agents searching for retained White House papers.
https:/
The law (in the Land of Free that is!) is straightforward. Title in the papers resides in the authorities and are NOT the personal property of the sitting president or thereafter. ABers wgi are not demented will recollect ( dimly perhaps) that this change was effectted after the wholesale destruction of papers during the Nixon admin.
er ABers need a question - is it fair that someone so fair, so dedicated to the good of he people so selfless, should be treated thus?
https:/
The law (in the Land of Free that is!) is straightforward. Title in the papers resides in the authorities and are NOT the personal property of the sitting president or thereafter. ABers wgi are not demented will recollect ( dimly perhaps) that this change was effectted after the wholesale destruction of papers during the Nixon admin.
er ABers need a question - is it fair that someone so fair, so dedicated to the good of he people so selfless, should be treated thus?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by Peter Pedant. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.
// PP - your (rare) questions are as incomprehensible as your answers//
Often, PP’s posts initially appear hard to understand, but they usually merit closer inspection. It’s a bit like reading Finnegans Wake. PP, like Joyce, is a mystery wrapped in a riddle inside an Enigma. But occasionally, the rotors are aligned, the steckerboard has been connected correctly, and the plaintext magically appears.
Often, PP’s posts initially appear hard to understand, but they usually merit closer inspection. It’s a bit like reading Finnegans Wake. PP, like Joyce, is a mystery wrapped in a riddle inside an Enigma. But occasionally, the rotors are aligned, the steckerboard has been connected correctly, and the plaintext magically appears.
With apologies to PP for hijacking his thread:
// But Finnegans Wake IS incomprehensible, or do you claim otherwise? //
I don’t claim to have read all of it, and I imagine very few have. Much of it looks like gibberish at first sight, but the text is full of allusions, jokes, puns and leitmotivs. There are as many ways of reading it as there are readers, but I see it on one level as a series of word games. In the same way that I feel a sense of satisfaction if I can solve one or two clues in a fiendish crossword, I derive enjoyment from identifying an obscure reference or pun in the text. Take the book’s first sentence as an example:
riverrun, past Eve and Adam’s, from swerve of shore to bend of bay, brings us by a commodius vicus of recirculation back to Howth Castle and Environs.
The first word, riverrun, refers to the River Liffey, which runs through Dublin, as well as ‘running’ (i.e. being a recurrent theme) through the book itself. It doesn’t begin with a capital, because the first sentence in the novel is a continuation of the last: Finnegan beginagain. (And yet, the book does begin with a capital, that capital being Dublin itself.)
“Eve and Adam’s” refers to the Church of St Francis of Assisi, also known as Adam and Eve’s church, which is on the banks of the Liffey. Adam and Eve also represent the beginning of humanity.
There’s nothing incomprehensible about ‘swerve of shore and bend of bay’, which together with ‘riverrun’ give the novel’s first sentence a mellifluous beauty.
‘Commodius’ alludes to ‘comfortable’ and also ‘commode’; with a hint of scatology, Joyce is referring to the Liffey’s function of flushing the city’s detritus into the Irish Sea. ‘Vicus’ means ‘settlement’ or ‘thoroughfare’ in Latin, and here refers both to the city and the river. It is also a pun on ‘vicious’, so that the ‘commodius vicus of recirculation’ becomes a vicious circle, as the water flows into the sea, where it evaporates and returns to the earth as rain to complete the cycle, just as the novel’s first sentence completes its last.
‘Howth Castle and Environs’ refers to the castle on the promontory on the northern side of Dublin Bay, into which the Liffey flows. The initial letters HCE also refer to many expressions in the book, including Humphrey Chimpden Earwicker, the main protagonist.
And that’s just the first sentence. There are doubtless dozens of references I have overlooked, but you get the general idea. Gibberish? Quite possibly. It could all be a great Joycean joke at the readers’ expense. Even if it is nothing but a load of dingoes’ kidneys, it still provides endless employment for the Majikthises and Vroomfondels in English departments around the world – well, at least the ones that haven’t cancelled Joyce yet...
// But Finnegans Wake IS incomprehensible, or do you claim otherwise? //
I don’t claim to have read all of it, and I imagine very few have. Much of it looks like gibberish at first sight, but the text is full of allusions, jokes, puns and leitmotivs. There are as many ways of reading it as there are readers, but I see it on one level as a series of word games. In the same way that I feel a sense of satisfaction if I can solve one or two clues in a fiendish crossword, I derive enjoyment from identifying an obscure reference or pun in the text. Take the book’s first sentence as an example:
riverrun, past Eve and Adam’s, from swerve of shore to bend of bay, brings us by a commodius vicus of recirculation back to Howth Castle and Environs.
The first word, riverrun, refers to the River Liffey, which runs through Dublin, as well as ‘running’ (i.e. being a recurrent theme) through the book itself. It doesn’t begin with a capital, because the first sentence in the novel is a continuation of the last: Finnegan beginagain. (And yet, the book does begin with a capital, that capital being Dublin itself.)
“Eve and Adam’s” refers to the Church of St Francis of Assisi, also known as Adam and Eve’s church, which is on the banks of the Liffey. Adam and Eve also represent the beginning of humanity.
There’s nothing incomprehensible about ‘swerve of shore and bend of bay’, which together with ‘riverrun’ give the novel’s first sentence a mellifluous beauty.
‘Commodius’ alludes to ‘comfortable’ and also ‘commode’; with a hint of scatology, Joyce is referring to the Liffey’s function of flushing the city’s detritus into the Irish Sea. ‘Vicus’ means ‘settlement’ or ‘thoroughfare’ in Latin, and here refers both to the city and the river. It is also a pun on ‘vicious’, so that the ‘commodius vicus of recirculation’ becomes a vicious circle, as the water flows into the sea, where it evaporates and returns to the earth as rain to complete the cycle, just as the novel’s first sentence completes its last.
‘Howth Castle and Environs’ refers to the castle on the promontory on the northern side of Dublin Bay, into which the Liffey flows. The initial letters HCE also refer to many expressions in the book, including Humphrey Chimpden Earwicker, the main protagonist.
And that’s just the first sentence. There are doubtless dozens of references I have overlooked, but you get the general idea. Gibberish? Quite possibly. It could all be a great Joycean joke at the readers’ expense. Even if it is nothing but a load of dingoes’ kidneys, it still provides endless employment for the Majikthises and Vroomfondels in English departments around the world – well, at least the ones that haven’t cancelled Joyce yet...
Latest Posts
ChatterBank1 min ago
Crosswords5 mins ago
Crosswords10 mins ago
Home & Garden15 mins ago
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.