News4 mins ago
Listener 4091: Mind the Gap by Calmac
71 Answers
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by AHearer. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.Well, like others I just ran through this, but was stumped by the unclued across until I sat down with a clear head this morning. I do not think it was particularly well constructed. Firstly, the unclued downs had no relevance, even to the unclued across, and might as well have been given clues. Secondly, it was not so much as a PDM as a look up the answer. For me, a PDM should arise out of the logic of the puzzle, clue structure, theme, so that you work through, step by step, until you see the light. Nothing in the puzzle actually led to that final moment. Disappointing all round :(
I also got there eventually. I saw the unclued across entry immediately this evening having stared at it for more than an hour yesterday - it is amazing how often that happens with the Listener! I had also convinced myself that the theme was something completely different (did anyone else think of tsunamis?)
Like Philoctetes I was underwhelmed by this. I couldn't really see much point to it since there was no developed theme as such, just a phrase that, unsurprisingly, is not in Chambers nor in my ODQ. Since there were various possibilities for the unclued down entries (bearing in mind the unspecified lengths) it was a while before I hit on the correct choices and saw a couple of words I recognised. The preamble hint is pretty obscure until you've arrived at the correct solution, so wasn't much help.
I have both the current Chambers and a very battered 7th edition. The phrase is in both. But as with a couple of previous respondents, having an entry in (almost) every light, I don't quite see the point of it all. A couple of hours to solve 90% of the clues, a couple of minutes of clarity to solve the remainder and a couple of days to decide that the final result is (probably) correct is not very intellectually satisfying.
Well I got there eventually - I think. Some easy clues but very tricky with the middle bit. Can't agree with those complaining about it being too easy. Those easy-ish clues get you started but unless you know the bit in the middle (I didn't), the title and preamble are not too much help.
I am left with one puzzle no one has mentioned. The square at the very centre of the puzzle seems to leave unsatisfactory fragments above and below. Am I missing the final piece of the puzzle here?
I am left with one puzzle no one has mentioned. The square at the very centre of the puzzle seems to leave unsatisfactory fragments above and below. Am I missing the final piece of the puzzle here?
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.