Us Presidents

[MarkyB1962]

As a quiz compiler,I obviously would like to make sure my answers are water tight.
This is for an odd one out:
John Adams;Thomas Jefferson;James Monroe;Calvin Coolidge.

The answer is Calvin Coolidge. The others died on 4 July and Coolidge was born on 4 July.
I know the danger behind these type of questions is of the different permutations - does anyone know any other permutations to this,or is the question and answer pretty sound?

[Jackdaw33]

This type of question is best avoided unless you suffix it with 'and why?' That gives you the opportunity to evaluate answers and award marks accordingly.

[Famous5]

Type Your Answer Here...John Adams is the only one whose son was also President

[Famous5]

And Jefferson is the only one carved on Mount Rushmore

[JJ109]

John Adams was born in Massachusetts

The other three were all born in states beginning with V
Jefferson and Monroe = Virginia. Coolidge = Vermont

[MarkyB1962]

Thanks for your answers. I am going down the line of giving out their names and saying "Three of them died on 4 July,which one was born on 4 July.

[fiction-factory]

That does make it very easy. Maybe ask the question as you originally had it but add something to say it's about calendars/dates/matter of life and death or give a hint about solving it 'Independently' (independence day)

[MarkyB1962]

Nice one fiction factory