I agree with you entirely factor. I was just trying to point out to Ignoblius where the flaw in his argument lies.
It's easy to see that he is wrong because his formula for the time difference does not depend on the initial velocity, but only on the difference between the initial and final velocities. So if the initial velocity were 1,000,000 m/s and the final velocity 1,000,020 he would get the same answer, which is obviously wrong!!