Donate SIGN UP

Do You Ever Get Advice From People Of Different Generations?

Avatar Image
Nameless14 | 14:33 Tue 26th Feb 2019 | Society & Culture
8 Answers
- If so, do you find the advice insightful or helpful? Do you ever find that it misses the mark?
- Have you ever noticed older generations giving advice to — and wanting to improve — young people? Have you found the advice insightful or helpful? Do you ever think that it misses the mark?
- Should older generations, as the author writes, help young people of color learn how to “tackle the systemic inequality that shapes black people’s lives in America?” Is that the most effective and empowering approach to education and meaningful social change?
- Or, should older generations instead help young people “fix themselves” — by changing what they wear, how they speak, or how they act, so they are more likely to be successful in America? And, is that approach, in the end, a better way to reduce systemic inequality?
- Are these two types of advice and mentorship mutually exclusive? Is only one approach the fair and just approach? Or can they both be effective?
- Do you think Mr. Obama is “scolding” black boys and “finger-wagging?” Is he calling out black children for making legitimate cultural choices instead of placing responsibility squarely on an unjust society? Or is he just being real about what it takes to be successful in America, based on his own experiences?
- Do you think there is a double standard for how black people and white people are supposed to dress to be successful?
Gravatar

Answers

1 to 8 of 8rss feed

Avatar Image
-yes -Yes, mostly helpful however usually from their own personal experience. - No, society changes and older generations don't live in the now as it could be said. So their perception / ideas are different. -No, young people need to learn who they are and fix themselves it's not up to someone else to do that for them. -No. What an odd question - they can both be...
14:37 Tue 26th Feb 2019

What are your answers Nameless, why not join in now and again?
-yes
-Yes, mostly helpful however usually from their own personal experience.
- No, society changes and older generations don't live in the now as it could be said. So their perception / ideas are different.
-No, young people need to learn who they are and fix themselves it's not up to someone else to do that for them.
-No. What an odd question
- they can both be effective. It's situational and subjective.
-No.
-No, any standard is racist, comparing either party from colour alone, is racist.
Nameless - are you looking for material for your homework, or are you asking genuine questions out of interest?

I have to say that the format of your OP's indicates the former.
This is an extract from the NY times article. Doe sit look familiar?
Students, read the entire essay, then tell us:

— Have you ever noticed older generations giving advice to — and wanting to improve — young people? Have you found the advice insightful or helpful? Do you ever think that it misses the mark?

— Should older generations, as the author writes, help young people of color learn how to “tackle the systemic inequality that shapes black people’s lives in America?” Is that the most effective and empowering approach to education and meaningful social change?

— Or, should older generations instead help young people “fix themselves” — by changing what they wear, how they speak, or how they act, so they are more likely to be successful in America? And, is that approach, in the end, a better way to reduce systemic inequality?

— Are these two types of advice and mentorship mutually exclusive? Is only one approach the fair and just approach? Or can they both be effective?

— Do you think Mr. Obama is “scolding” black boys and “finger-wagging?” Is he calling out black children for making legitimate cultural choices instead of placing responsibility squarely on an unjust society? Or is he just being real about what it takes to be successful in America, based on his own experiences?

— A comment selected as a Times Pick states: “Paradoxically, international fashion trends right now are heavily derived from black hip-hop and black athletic culture. Karl Lagerfeld made heavy hip-hop derived chains a signature of his daily look. Apparently it’s ok to ‘dress black’ so long as you’re white with status.” Do you think there is a double standard for how black people and white people are supposed to dress to be successful?
Maybe our reposnses on here get published by Nameless as his answers on the NY Times forum which invites essay responses from students aged 13+.
His/her previous posts have also been copied and pated from the NY Times
Generational considerations are not something I consider much when seeking advice. Ultimately advice is just advice; it is I who makes the final decision.

Never felt the need to seek out advice on being a black man in America. If I tried that umpteen folk would opt to claim to be offended by the black make-up.
Nameless - me, older generation giving you, younger generation, why don't you go and post elsewhere?

The only good thing about your posts is that reading them takes about the right time to cook a boiled egg.

1 to 8 of 8rss feed

Do you know the answer?

Do You Ever Get Advice From People Of Different Generations?

Answer Question >>

Related Questions

Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.