Geezer, who has never had the stigmata, can still pass judgment on those like Padre Pio, who have. Amazing. There are false cases, there are true cases. If you must through out your own discriminating powers because certain answers will never be acceptable to you, then why pretend to be asking. St Francis was hardly a fraud. And at the least, his stigmata with his explanation are head and shoulders above your lack of stigmata and your self-justifying 'explanation'.