Quizzes & Puzzles23 mins ago
Can anyone explain the growth of Islam in the UK?
30 Answers
After 9/11, 7/7 and seemingly nothing but endless bad publicity, with its harsh attitude towards women and homosexuals and so forth, you'd have thought that Islam would be immensely unpopular in the UK. Yet, unless I'm very much mistaken, it s popularity appears to have increased hugely in all that time. Unless it attracts disaffected types who convert almost to stick two fingers up to family and friends they want to shock, I cannot fathom why Brits who do not have origins in Muslim countries have been drawn to Islam. Can anyone explain the appeal? I'd be particularly interested to read posts from those who have become converts.
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by chirpychirpy. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.I should have added that I realise the general increase will have been down to immigration and breeding within the Muslim people. What I'm interested in knowing about is why so many people with previously no connection to Islam have converted. Maybe it's a case of any publicity is good publicity. Or maybe they think that, if there is to be a War or Islam does eventually succeed in taking over this country, these people want to be on what they foresee as the winning side.
-- answer removed --
Although I am Muslim myself so perhaps my view will not make any impression but I must say that this conversion is more in USA than in the UK. However wherever it is, the reason I can think of that due to the bad publicity or propaganda spread on media, more people started studying Islam themselves instead of believing what others told them. And they found out that all what they ever believed about Islam were misconceptions and nothing more. I could be wrong as well.
I would agree that there is a larger influx of conversions to Islam among native UK people than usual.
There will always be a section of disaffected youth who will adopt a controversial standpoint in order to establish a position of non-conformity, and a religious faith - or at least the superficial trappings of it - are always a good place to start.
As with any faith or creed, it is not the faith that attracts news interest - it is the extremist version, and the deeds carried out by people who adhere to extreme views - and this is true of any faith.
The majority of Muslims adhere to the peaceful aspects of their faith, and carry on with blameless lives - but that's not news - or worth attatching to as a radical statement.
I would be interested in seeing any evidence you have to supporrt your hpothesis chirpy.
There will always be a section of disaffected youth who will adopt a controversial standpoint in order to establish a position of non-conformity, and a religious faith - or at least the superficial trappings of it - are always a good place to start.
As with any faith or creed, it is not the faith that attracts news interest - it is the extremist version, and the deeds carried out by people who adhere to extreme views - and this is true of any faith.
The majority of Muslims adhere to the peaceful aspects of their faith, and carry on with blameless lives - but that's not news - or worth attatching to as a radical statement.
I would be interested in seeing any evidence you have to supporrt your hpothesis chirpy.
stupid impressionable people have always been drawn to religion
it makes no difference to me if this lot have been converted or not....from whatever fairy tale they may blindly follow
its only when religion affects me and normal citizens that it should be tackled head on by society
if they wish to eliminate people who arent in their club for no other reason than we dont give a monkeys about their habits then i take exception
religious extremists of any following have no place in civilised society
it makes no difference to me if this lot have been converted or not....from whatever fairy tale they may blindly follow
its only when religion affects me and normal citizens that it should be tackled head on by society
if they wish to eliminate people who arent in their club for no other reason than we dont give a monkeys about their habits then i take exception
religious extremists of any following have no place in civilised society
More interesting would be the figures compared to converts of other religions.
I strongly suspect they would be quite low. Converting to islam is not the issue for this country, it is letting in swathes of unchecked fundamentalists that pose the threat.
I have said it before and I'll say it again. There will be war over this. Religion is the point of all evil. Without religion the world would be a far better place.
I strongly suspect they would be quite low. Converting to islam is not the issue for this country, it is letting in swathes of unchecked fundamentalists that pose the threat.
I have said it before and I'll say it again. There will be war over this. Religion is the point of all evil. Without religion the world would be a far better place.
Wikipedia has a page devoted to the various claims that a particular religion is the fastest growing
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claims_to_be_the_fastest_growing_religion
Rather amusingly there are claims from various Christian denominations, Islam, Falun Gong, Budhism, Hinduism and even Wicca to this dubious honour and several more besides.
Why do people convert? Well I'm fairly impressed with some of the seperated twins studies which seem to show that people have a genetic tendency to be religious or not religious. If therefore someone with a tendency to be religious becomes disenchanted with their faith (or lack of it ) and someone gets to them at that time with a message they prefer they're likely to convert.
So why would they be disenchanted? A lot of Christian churches are rather caught in a liberal/conservative divide and will be making both conservatives and liberals unhappy. Islam is likely to appeal to conservatives especially those uncomfortable with the slightly more paganistic and polytheistic themes in parts of Christianity. (The trinity, Saints and statues,crucifixes and religious art , transmutation of the host all the hocus pocus)
Don't fall into the trap of thinking that all moslems are screaming jihadi-crazed sword wielding maniacs. Some Christians will think that way and when they find out that's not the case they'll be intrigued and be drawn in.
But I think JNO's absolutely wrong - I think there are a lot of people who join religions (and even more stay in them) for a sense of community - of being with like-minded people
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claims_to_be_the_fastest_growing_religion
Rather amusingly there are claims from various Christian denominations, Islam, Falun Gong, Budhism, Hinduism and even Wicca to this dubious honour and several more besides.
Why do people convert? Well I'm fairly impressed with some of the seperated twins studies which seem to show that people have a genetic tendency to be religious or not religious. If therefore someone with a tendency to be religious becomes disenchanted with their faith (or lack of it ) and someone gets to them at that time with a message they prefer they're likely to convert.
So why would they be disenchanted? A lot of Christian churches are rather caught in a liberal/conservative divide and will be making both conservatives and liberals unhappy. Islam is likely to appeal to conservatives especially those uncomfortable with the slightly more paganistic and polytheistic themes in parts of Christianity. (The trinity, Saints and statues,crucifixes and religious art , transmutation of the host all the hocus pocus)
Don't fall into the trap of thinking that all moslems are screaming jihadi-crazed sword wielding maniacs. Some Christians will think that way and when they find out that's not the case they'll be intrigued and be drawn in.
But I think JNO's absolutely wrong - I think there are a lot of people who join religions (and even more stay in them) for a sense of community - of being with like-minded people
-- answer removed --
yes, I think that's a fair point, jake - the Anglican Church in particular fulfils a function that is as much social as religious; in theory everyone in the country ought to be able to go to a service without hearing anything too upsetting. I'm not sure signing up to this counts as 'conversion', though.
-- answer removed --
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.