Sorry, bit late in on this one.
I make the answer 37, but ichkeria’s solution is incorrect as it involves 21, which of course is not a prime number. DT’s solution is also invalid because (a) it only amounts to 31 and (b) it involves calls of 1, 9, 16, 18, 24, and 26. My solution (there may be others):
5 reds (5)
Pink (11)
2 reds (13)
Pink (19)
4 reds (23)
Pink (29)
2 reds (31)
Pink (37)
After that you need to get to 41, but you’ve only 2 reds left.
BTW, I don’t make the maximum (theoretical) score in one shot 16, DT. How is it done?