Phil Dowd

[grumpy01]

How is this p???k refereeing in the premier league? Beats me./

[Milvus]

Because his penalty decision was correct

[grumpy01]

Penalty correct but you can't play advantage that long should have given it first.Still his favourite team haven't won anything this time.

[DrFilth]

is he a droylsden fan ?

[Milvus]

There isn't a time limit on advantage. He allowed it to continue until the move broke down. Which is correct

[ChillDoubt]

He followed the UEFA directive to the letter and the studio pundits on MOTD2 concurred 100% with his decision.

Looked a common sense, absolutely correct decision to me.

[grumpy01]

You've been reading 3 yellow's Poll then Milvus.

[angie55]

//Penalty correct but you can't play advantage that long should have given it first.Still his favourite team haven't won anything this time.//

Grumpy - who says you can't play advantage that long? And your last sentence is irrelevant to the discussion.

[grumpy01]

No not irrelevant.When Manure played Aston Villa in League Cup final a few season's ago Vidic should have been sent off for preventing a goal scoring opportunity but Dowd deemed a booking suitable.

[angie55]

Sorry, I didn't realise you were another of the hate Man Utd brigade. You obviously don't support a team as you spend so much time hating another. Really sad. And you haven't said why advantage can't be played for that long?

And no, I'm not a Man Utd fan and never have been.