LOL Jen !!!! You are about to have a rollercoaster of a time with Heathcliffe.... I can remember being handed back a very wet bundle of fluffy tabby kitten by a (only slightly irate) neighbour... who declared.... "Is this yours ? If so, I rescued him from my pond...." and then another week, same neighbour handed same kitten back with the comment, "Is this yours, I rescued him from my apple tree...."
My wee thug managed to get into a neighbours house recently and *ahem* devoured their little boy's pet rat.... ooops ! Thank goodness it was a pet rat and not a wild one..... imagine the diseases that could have been carrying... mind, the neighbour was a bit upset ! I had to buy the lad two new pet rats to replace his lost one... but he had to promise me to keep them in their cages from now on....