A Little Experiment ............

[Gizmonster]

This is NOT a test to see how good your punctuation is, but something else - which I shall reveal later ..... or it may well be revealed by others on here :)

All I want you to do, is punctuate the following sentence AND state whether you're male or female .... all shall be revealed :)

Please do NOT look at any of the other answers before you reply, as I don't want you influenced in any way.

The sentence is:

A woman without her man is nothing

[Old_Geezer]

A woman without; her man is nothing.

[Muntin]

a woman, without her, man is nothing.