Donate SIGN UP

Johnson's "new" Deal

Avatar Image
jim360 | 11:24 Thu 17th Oct 2019 | News
32 Answers
So far so quiet on AB, but since the new Deal* (text available at the bottom) has now been announced, what are people's thoughts?

https://ec.europa.eu/commission/publications/revised-withdrawal-agreement_en

https://ec.europa.eu/commission/publications/revised-political-declaration_en
Gravatar

Answers

21 to 32 of 32rss feed

First Previous 1 2

Avatar Image
To answer your question directly jim: are they happy that the UK still will pay the EU approx. £40 billion in the next decade? No, not really but if we are to appease the remainers then I can't see that anything else would ever happen. Are they still comfortable with a transition period, extending to as late as 2021? Yes & No. A transition is needed though for both...
11:57 Thu 17th Oct 2019
Dont be pathetic jno, jim asked a very reasonable question.

Try answering it.
Democracy has not failed the electorate, undemocratic MPs egged on by undemocratic remainers have.
MPs should represent their own constituency when it's a constituency matter, and represent the nation's view on matters decided nationwide. They might also choose to vote according to their own conscience if they have no conscience regarding failing in their duty to represent the people that they are meant to be representing; in which case they need to be slung out of politics as soon as possible.
/// There is if a democratic referendum hasn't been implemented in three and a half years......it is a nonsense in the name of democracy.///

It wasn't a democratic referendum as electoral laws were broken by Leave.

And in 3 and a half years a lot of people can change their minds.

The Leave camp get more and more vociferous banging on about democracy which wasn't valid - they are getting desperate to ruin the country economically (which will win Jacob and his cronies lots and lota of money).
Based on Jim's synopsis questions.

It's a bad thing to be paying the mugger but if it gets us out it may be worth tolerating.

Further delay would be unacceptable but if we transitioned to a basically out situation quickly and simply took a while tying up the loose ends it could be accepted through gritted teeth.

Not in the slightest happy with the EU still ruling NI. That needs to be progressed quickly so it no longer stands.

And related, not the slightest bit happy with an internal national border, which was rightly described as unacceptable, but await the details to see how that's going to fade away quickly.

I've no idea of the consequences of joint committee overseeing. Just so long as meanings aren't twisted to keep us in.

Not aware of the rest of proposed agreement having yet to read it, but if the rest is May's attempt untouched then that sounds like a potential BRINO to me. I await expert analysis on it, but it suggests it's failed.
It was £350 million a week before all this started, I imagine the constant extensions have cost a good deal more, though I have not seen any figures relating to this.
It's not democracy if some muck about delaying, and spreading doom rumours, for three years in the hope of thwarting the decision. It has no relevancy to the fact that we opted out and out we must eventually be, or fail to be nothing more than mere pawns to the ruling elite.
"Jean-Claude Juncker told reporters: "I was ruling out that there would be any kind of prolongation. "If we have a deal we have a deal and there is no need for prolongation." "
This appears to be Mrs May’s deal, but with a tweak to the backstop.
I suggested a while back that Mr Johnson would do this and claim he has negotiated a different deal.
There is no doubt that he has hit brick walls at every turn, but this is as bad as the previous version.
A face and career saving result for him. BRINO for the rest of us.
There is no backstop now. It’s basically a free trade deal for the EU and GB with NI left out. So I am not surprised the DUP aren’t happy.
But that is what Brexit means for Ireland: either the above, or NI and the ROI gradually drifting further apart.
Makes you wonder even more why the DUP supported Brexit in the first place. They don’t seem to like the reality of it (in fairness they are not alone in that)
I see Farage has hit out at the EU apparently ruling out an extension. Calling them a “thuggocracy”.
There’s just no pleasing some people :-)
Try answering it.

I'm not sure what question you're talking about, ymb? I haven't been trying to answer jim, or suggesting his questions have been anything but reasonable. I have been responding to other posts.
Question Author
Thanks to ymb and OG in particular for giving such answers to my series of questions. The only remaining question, I suppose, is what MPs think!

21 to 32 of 32rss feed

First Previous 1 2

Do you know the answer?

Johnson's "new" Deal

Answer Question >>