saintpeter48 the last European Cup (as opposed to Champions League) was played in 1991, Fernando Torres would have been 7 years old at that time,
English clubs that won the European cup and First division titles were Liverpool, Forest, Aston Villa, and Man Utd. Of those only Liverpool won 4 first division titles around the time of the European Cup wins. Therefore you can really just look at the players listed in the Liverpool team for the Supercup. As most played only for Liverpool, not as many short term transfers as today, it is just a question of finding one who was a runner up in the FA Cup with another team. Jimmy Case fits the bill.