I do sympathise as I had this problem a few years ago. I had however collected every school league table since they came out, so I could go through those and see how schools averaged out, every school can have a particularly good or bad year, so if you can find a few years worth of the league tables I would recommend doing this. Yes, I did also check the OFSTED reports but I also 'googled' each school and area to see what came up. I narrowed it down to four schools, choosing ones which were consistently good in the league tables, but not necessarily top fivers as I think that those schools can concentrate too much on getting good SATs results and there is much more to school than just those. I then made appointments at each school (I only had two days to do this in) and found that that really made my mind up. One school I was very impressed with, the others all had things which I wasn't too sure about, but just to put my mind at ease I went back to the school I was pretty sure I wanted my children to attend at home time and just watched the mothers waiting for their children to assure myself that they (and the children) seemed happy and normal (I didn't want a 'chav' school nor a really posh one). I am satisfied that I made the right choice. Only gut instict can really help. Good luck.