Elves - immortal or just simply, dont die of old age?

PaulYukochan | 16:02 Sun 01st Dec 2002 | Film, Media & TV

6 Answers

THe elves in lord of the rings are immortal. Yet they can die of grief or be slain. HOw is this immortal?

Song used in an Advert....

Lyric Translation Hunt for Red October

Answers

1 to 6 of 6

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by PaulYukochan. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.

-- answer removed --

PaulYukochan

Question Author

Sorry Tartan witch, but how can an immortal being die, it is a contradiction! Either you are immortal, or not. Surely!

-- answer removed --

JohnPPotts

It would be more accurate to describe elves as "Unaging but mortal", as they can be killed. Although when elves die they go to Tol Eressa (sort of Heaven) and they can come back (unless they've been especially bad - Feanor isn't allowed to return, for example). And I've just exposed myself as a total Tolkien nerd!

andy hughes

Elvis's 'imortality' is not connected to his physical being, but to his talent, and the body of work he left behind, and its continuing appeal and influence, which are, indeed, immortal.

Pippin4242

It was my belief that Elves are not unchanging as such... that they merely age extremely slowly and that the symptons of aging can be aggravated by factors such as grief, pain or any extreme of emotion. Though no quotes spring to mind I should imagine that Maedhros, for example, aged pretty quickly up there of Thangorodrim.

1 to 6 of 6

Do you know the answer?