Brian Johnson or Bon Scott?

[Myriad2112]

Two singers, one band, Who will win?
You decide ....

[cyanide]

Oh Bon Scott without a doubt!!
I hated AC/DC when Brian joined,he just couldn`t cut the mustard!
Back in Black was excellent....until he opened his gob!!

[andy-hughes]

I'm not a major fan, but i do think Bon Scott whiskey-tinged vocals did go so well with their dirty rock and roll.

My favourite is 'Rocker' - when my daughter was six, we used to sing it on the way to school!

[cyanide]

Loving your work andy-hughes!!

[paulos66]

It's not the messiah it's Brian

[soozmac]

Oh. My. God. I can't believe you're even asking this! Bon's voice was smooth like melted chocolate, and it pours out the speakers to smother you - he had soul, and passion, and groove, and a cheeky lilt to his voice. Brian is nothing but a screecher compared to Bon, and it's so sad to see AC/DC being remembered for his dreadful dreadful "singing." I love Back In Black, but I can't help thinking what an amazing album it would have been, could have been, if Bon hadn't been so reckless that night in London. I've been to his memorial in Fremantle Cemetery just outside Perth in Australia (there is no grave as such, as he was cremated), where I tidied up and left some fresh flowers.

[perigra]

bon scott, without a doubt!

[sheffwed39]

no two ways about it. bon scott far superior

[TTG]

Bon was great.. Brian was good until his voice started to fail. Ballbreaker and Stiff Upper Lip would have been good if his voice had been good.