News2 mins ago
Photographs of moving rods
6 Answers
A rod of length L is parallel to the surface of a photographic plate a distance d above it, and moves in a direction along its length. A light flash, of negligible duration, illuminates the plate at normal incidence while the rod is in front of it. How long is the photograph of the shadow according to obsevers in both the reference frame of the plate and that of the rod? How does the observer moving wtih the rod reconcile this shadow with the known length of the rod?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by 1morethicko. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.COOOOL QUESTION!
I think it's actually a trick question, one of these ones that fills out lots of detail to take you down one path, which is a red herring. This red herring is contraction along a length relative to another length in a parallel plane.
Mini-caveat (1) : ignore the light position, casting a larger shadow, etc. It can't be about that. Light diffuses outwards (in an area the square of the distance from the source). I think since this information is missing, you can assume that the flash is itself just 'diffuse'.
Mini-caveat (2): Ignore any thoughts of 'oh, the rod is moving, so by the time the light gets to the plate, it will create a shadow of different length on the plate due to the movement of the rod.' The instantaneity of the light flash rules this out.
Sooo...you get thinking about relativity. The length of the rod will contract, with movement, relative to a length in a parallel plane that is moving at a different speed in the parallel plane. So you measure the length of the rod from 'rest' position, ie as an observer on the rod. You compare it to the length of the 'rod' on the other plane: the plate. Therein lies the red herring. You are comparing the rod's length NOT between reference frames, rod to plate, but within the same reference frame: the rod's length is always the same on the rod and its shadow: the shadow moves just at the same speed as the rod, it just happens to be projected on the plate. The plate is a different reference frame to the rod, but so what? The speed properties of the shadow relate directly to the speed of the rod, and are nothing to do with the plate.
The length is the same on the plate and the rod.
I think it's actually a trick question, one of these ones that fills out lots of detail to take you down one path, which is a red herring. This red herring is contraction along a length relative to another length in a parallel plane.
Mini-caveat (1) : ignore the light position, casting a larger shadow, etc. It can't be about that. Light diffuses outwards (in an area the square of the distance from the source). I think since this information is missing, you can assume that the flash is itself just 'diffuse'.
Mini-caveat (2): Ignore any thoughts of 'oh, the rod is moving, so by the time the light gets to the plate, it will create a shadow of different length on the plate due to the movement of the rod.' The instantaneity of the light flash rules this out.
Sooo...you get thinking about relativity. The length of the rod will contract, with movement, relative to a length in a parallel plane that is moving at a different speed in the parallel plane. So you measure the length of the rod from 'rest' position, ie as an observer on the rod. You compare it to the length of the 'rod' on the other plane: the plate. Therein lies the red herring. You are comparing the rod's length NOT between reference frames, rod to plate, but within the same reference frame: the rod's length is always the same on the rod and its shadow: the shadow moves just at the same speed as the rod, it just happens to be projected on the plate. The plate is a different reference frame to the rod, but so what? The speed properties of the shadow relate directly to the speed of the rod, and are nothing to do with the plate.
The length is the same on the plate and the rod.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.