New dark shadows and circles under eye roll ons.......any good?

[lilacben]

Has anyone tried the two new eye roll ons they advertise on tv. Think they are Loreal and Garneia.? It is for dark shadows and lines ect. under eyes. Have looked at both in the shop but would like to hear from someone who has tried it first. And most importantly if it works.

[chazza]

I use the coloured one and it does cover dark circles under my eyes. I'm not sure if there's any benefit to the roller ball though. I don't tend to roll it on, rather dab it as it would apply too much of the product if I rolled it on