I think I've sussed Silent Witness

[madmaggot]

I think that the father is the killer; the chap that was convicted was his gay lover and the daughter caught them and that's why he killed her.
The one that was convicted confessed to protect his lover, the father. that was why he gave incorrect evidence about how he picked her up (her friend said she walked with her to her door), to keep suspicion away from her father.
Anyone agree?

[chelle7272]

I had suspicions about the father, but couldn't get the rest.
Sounds pretty good to me, but who grabbed the wpman at the end, looked like a younger chap?

[Ankou]

i'll give it 5 minutes tonight to suss this one out.
i solved* the last one just before the end of episode 1.






* guessed right

[Francis Asis]

No I totally disagree. It was suicide.

[carlton23]

Hi maggot, you should go and help the police with Joanna Yeates murder.

[Large-end]

Its only a tv programme.

[ummmm]

You was almost right madmaggot..

[Large-end]

Close but no cigar i say.

[carlton23]

Who was Jack the Ripper then?

[mata hati]

Maybe being a bit thick here but I still dont understand it! Did the son murder his sister and the all other girls? Wouldnt he have been too young to have committed the others if they were done in the late eighties? Did he kill the one they found buried? and who was the lover of the man in prison? the father or the son?

[mollykins]

I knew it was either the dad or brother.

[T&S]

I didn't see this weeks, but I sussed last weeks within minutes of Episode 1 starting.

[ummmm]

Mata - it was the brother. His sister seen him and the one in prison kissing...and so he killed her.

[chelle7272]

Nearly there madmaggot.

Mata - yes the brother did all of them - he would have been young but past school age I should think. He was having an affair with the guy in prison for the murders who was supplying him with ketamine and took the blame for him.
And his sister as ummmm said.

Agree with others last weeks was quite obvious.

[Francis Asis]

Maggot I am impressed. You were so close. When i read your theory yesterday I admit I thought it was rubbish. I was convinced it was the policeman. Never gave the son a thought.

[madmaggot]

Oh well, can't win 'em all!