Ah yes, I read the first bit about Surcare and admit to scanning down after that :-O
My concentration not being what it used to be.
I did wonder how good they were. Bit skeptical to be honest but not wanting to pooh pooh something if it worked. doesn't seem like I should change for them then.
OG I think that it depends on what kind of washing you have - I have 2 very active boys so their stuff tends to me really manky and I wouldn't rely on "magic" to get them clean.
Ariel powder because I have found the others don't get stains out and I end up having to do it again. I bulkbuy it when they have it reduced and stockpile it in the garage.
I'm still using some home-made stuff from months ago. My OH used to travel a lot and always brought little bars of soap home from the hotels, we ended up with loads of these little bars so I turned them into powder.