hbp

[potterfan3]

ever since i finished hbp a few questions about it 1 is snape still a good guy i know he killed dumbledore but if he hadn't he would of died so maybe he told snape to kill so he can carry on being a spy 2 RAB i think it maybe regulas black (serious's brother) we never got told his middle name and he was a death eater so he would of called him the dark lord 3 harry 4 hogwarts in book 7 i know he said he wouldn't go back but 7books 7years at hogwarts right 4 what did you think of it people i asked said it wasn't as good as the others

[mycatis]

Could you please put any spoilers in the question, it's not fair on people who haben't read it

[potterfan3]

i did put spoilers and what does haben't mean?

[kezza001]

i'm confuddled bout snape but hes abit of a bad guy 4 me now

[Golem]

What did I think of it?

Well, since you ask, I think Ms Rowlings provides an excellent example of contemporary children's literature with well thought-out sentence structuring, grammar, use of punctuation and pacing. The narrative development places the denouement towards the end after giving clues to the reader of what may be about to happen. The names she chooses for her many and varied characters are clever and amusing and their significance is surely not lost on the more astute and discerning reader.

What did you think?

[Piper-AK]

There's another thread ref this same question. Also, I'm sorry to be a pedant but could you use some punctuation in your question next time? I found it almost impossible to read.

To answer your question, I really liked the book. At first I thought that Dumbledore maybe wasn't really Dumbledore but someone polyjuiced to look like him - changed my mind as I think when whoever it was died the magic would stop and they would revert to looking like themselves. I think Snape must be a good guy, and Dumbledore told him to kill him to avoid giving the game away or something. If Snape isn't a good guy, Dumbledore was wrong for once in his life and I can't believe that!

[Celtigra3]

For a comprehensive guide to all Harry Potter stuff, try the website www.mugglenet.com I think you will find answers to your queries there.

[pixi]

potterfan before pulling people up on a typo, maybe you should take a look at your own post!!! I couldnt even read it because of the lack of punctuation.

[sophieb]

I agree with all of you about the punctuation. And thanks for spoiling the book for me, potterfan3 ! I have not read it yet but seems little point now! I hate when people do this. If you need to ask so many questions about what you have already read maybe you should go back and read it again to try and find out!!

[potterfan3]

I'm sorry to who ever i ruined the book for anyone, and i future i would be cafeful to use puntuation properly, and to answer Golem's question i thought it was cheesy.