How it Works2 mins ago
Anything specific to help a cough
39 Answers
My Dad picked up a cold which has resulted in a nasty cough for the past couple of weeks- sort of between wheezy and chesty. All he's been taking is these cold and flu hot drinks which have no effect at all.
He has COPD which I'm sure doesn't help and hearing the way he coughs is painful to listen to but he's not the type to 'bother' doctors.
Is there anything specific he could take to help eliviate it? Do any of these cough medicines have any effect?
He has COPD which I'm sure doesn't help and hearing the way he coughs is painful to listen to but he's not the type to 'bother' doctors.
Is there anything specific he could take to help eliviate it? Do any of these cough medicines have any effect?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by EvianBaby. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.Does he like honey? Try asking him to take a spoonful neat a few times a day and let it trickle down his throat. But quite honestly it sounds as if he does need to see a doctor, do you have any friends who are medically minded who could explain the seriousness of ignoring it, the elderly often take notice of people who are not "family" - I know this from experience with my stubborn father-in-law.
-- answer removed --
-- answer removed --
@methyl......you said that Benylin "caused " your cough........that is nonsense........it may not have "cured" your cough, but it certainly didn't "cause" it as you said.
Benylin "may" be addictive if abused.......yes .....I do recall.
Surely buying over the counter medicines can be done with an element of common sense...i.e if the cough persists, then visit the doctor........not the other way round.
Benylin "may" be addictive if abused.......yes .....I do recall.
Surely buying over the counter medicines can be done with an element of common sense...i.e if the cough persists, then visit the doctor........not the other way round.
-- answer removed --
methyl
I agree with your first statement except
\\One way to make things so much worse is to take Expectorants or other drugs when you don't need them. \\\
How will this make his condition worse? It may not "improve " his condition but I can't see how it will make it "worse"
Secondly,,,,he won't see a doctor...we ALL agree that he should....but he won't and you can't force the guy. I get the impression that he knows what he is doing and doesnt feel it is necessary to see the GP...I might be wrong......but again....the decision is HIS and the questioner wants to know if anything will alleviate it.
You last statement i don't understand..........but will respect it.
I agree with your first statement except
\\One way to make things so much worse is to take Expectorants or other drugs when you don't need them. \\\
How will this make his condition worse? It may not "improve " his condition but I can't see how it will make it "worse"
Secondly,,,,he won't see a doctor...we ALL agree that he should....but he won't and you can't force the guy. I get the impression that he knows what he is doing and doesnt feel it is necessary to see the GP...I might be wrong......but again....the decision is HIS and the questioner wants to know if anything will alleviate it.
You last statement i don't understand..........but will respect it.
Warm water with honey, lemon and little brandy. Or gargle with a little brandy, that will help the germs. I read somewhere that a soluble disprin (or is it aspirin? whichever one you can dissolve) is a good gargle for germs as well. I found the first remedy helped my hacking cough a few weeks ago. Dont waste your money on Beechams or a shop bought cough medicine plus they taste vile. I used to like Galloways cough mixture but I think its been discontinued. Night Nurse tablets will help but again dont buy the syrup. Ugh.
-- answer removed --
Well, look what happens when you dont look at your answers for a few hours. :)
Didnt get a chance to go to the pharmacy but from answers it looks like that would have been pointless anyway.
I should point out his current meds are not related to the COPD (well i dont think so anyway). Mostly simvastatins.
I think i also have may have given the impression he's a bit frail and incapable. He's not, he is 64 and still working. He is just very stubborn and believes all remedies will just fix themselves.
He would seriously not appreciate me going behind his back to the docs so for now ill just suggest some honey based concoctions and some gentle nudges about speaking to a doc or nurse.
Thanks for all the answers, all very apprciated.
Didnt get a chance to go to the pharmacy but from answers it looks like that would have been pointless anyway.
I should point out his current meds are not related to the COPD (well i dont think so anyway). Mostly simvastatins.
I think i also have may have given the impression he's a bit frail and incapable. He's not, he is 64 and still working. He is just very stubborn and believes all remedies will just fix themselves.
He would seriously not appreciate me going behind his back to the docs so for now ill just suggest some honey based concoctions and some gentle nudges about speaking to a doc or nurse.
Thanks for all the answers, all very apprciated.
I've heard about the saltpipe on This Morning a few years ago. It might be worth a try. Perhaps you could google more about it:
Amazon.co.uk User Recommendation
Amazon.co.uk User Recommendation
Here's another link about the saltpipe and it does mention COPD
http://www.thesaltpip...uk/about-saltpipe.php
http://www.thesaltpip...uk/about-saltpipe.php
Methyl - sqad may not be a pharmacist, but he's been a senior clinician in the health service in his time, so don't make assumptions :-(
If this were posted in the Health topic rather than B&S, evian would see the health warning posted there, that the advice on here is no subsistute for seeing the patient's own doctor.
COPD is a serious and life-threatening condition, so please, evian - get him to see the GP, for your sake if not for his. All the adverts say that anyone with a cough for over 3 weeks should see the doc - use that as your excuse to get him to go, if you don't want him to know that you are aware about the COPD diagnosis.
If this were posted in the Health topic rather than B&S, evian would see the health warning posted there, that the advice on here is no subsistute for seeing the patient's own doctor.
COPD is a serious and life-threatening condition, so please, evian - get him to see the GP, for your sake if not for his. All the adverts say that anyone with a cough for over 3 weeks should see the doc - use that as your excuse to get him to go, if you don't want him to know that you are aware about the COPD diagnosis.
From the NHS website:
http://www.nhs.uk/Con.../Pages/Treatment.aspx
http://www.nhs.uk/Con.../Pages/Treatment.aspx