X Factor winner Shane

[ems27]

I remember watching the beginning of the series (the ist auditions) and a guy with a cast on his arm auditioned and got through. he was very cute and said he hurt his arm falling over a baby gate. I've always asumed this was Shane cos he was the spit of him. However, yesterday i saw the video for Shanes' single Thats my Goal and it shows a clip of his first autition but there is no cast on his arm. Have i just been wrong all this time ??

[chazza]

I think so. I remember Shane's first audition and he didnt have a cast.

[leighclara]

It wasnt Shayne with the cast on his arm - it was a guy called Max George. He didnt get through bootcamp!