Jobs & Education1 min ago
A Legal Mind To Advise On Dispute With Water Company.
I live in a row of 12 bungalows. A new tenant has found out that our water company has been charging us to take away foul water but the water drains into the gardens and does not go through the main sewers. He informed us all, and most have queried this with the water company, who knew about this all along but continued to charge for this service. Without quibble they have agreed to amend their bills for next year and credit us for this year. One tenant has been paying this for over 20 years and myself 5 years. They have refused to backdate the claims and say it was our responsibility to inform them that the rain/foul water was not going into the main sewers. To me, this is fraud. ie charging for a service that they wilfully knew they were not providing. How do we stand legally?
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by rebelboy. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.I can't help you legally but I think you'll find your "Foul" water goes to the sewers. Your "Surface" water (i.e. rain) is the water which goes to soakaways and this is what you are wrongly being billed for.
Just thought! Perhaps you mean your foul water is going to a septic tank somewhere. Then they shouldn't be charging for that either.
Have you got a septic tank?
Just thought! Perhaps you mean your foul water is going to a septic tank somewhere. Then they shouldn't be charging for that either.
Have you got a septic tank?
-- answer removed --
I'm still a little confused as to what the problem is.
If you look at your water bill is the water incoming the same as the water outgoing?
Some water companies do offer a discount for those who harvest rainwater for watering the garden and flushing toilets. Is this the discount that is being offered?
If you look at your water bill is the water incoming the same as the water outgoing?
Some water companies do offer a discount for those who harvest rainwater for watering the garden and flushing toilets. Is this the discount that is being offered?
Ok I also have no law expertise but, opinions I have aplenty.
From your posts it sounds as if you are sure the foul water is being dumped on the land somehow. I think you need to confirm this is the case first, since if sewer water or indeed anything else is taken away then the bill is legitimate.
If there really is no foul water removal by the company then as mentioned in posts above there would need to be a septic tank somewhere which you periodically have emptied.
For sure an ombudsman is a good start, but beware, I was "using" one once and discovered they don't really take your side against the powerful commercial concern. They say they are there to mediate and bring the parties together but I found nothing changed for ages, followed by a letter from him saying as he hadn't heard anything he took it all was ok and settled now !!! But it's better than nothing I suppose.
From your posts it sounds as if you are sure the foul water is being dumped on the land somehow. I think you need to confirm this is the case first, since if sewer water or indeed anything else is taken away then the bill is legitimate.
If there really is no foul water removal by the company then as mentioned in posts above there would need to be a septic tank somewhere which you periodically have emptied.
For sure an ombudsman is a good start, but beware, I was "using" one once and discovered they don't really take your side against the powerful commercial concern. They say they are there to mediate and bring the parties together but I found nothing changed for ages, followed by a letter from him saying as he hadn't heard anything he took it all was ok and settled now !!! But it's better than nothing I suppose.
As you correctly say, this is the discount that applies if the surface water from the downpours drains into soakaways and not down the foul drain sewer. However you are completely wrong to assert it is fraud because the water companies have no way of knowing which houses drain in this manner. When the legislation was amended to enable this discount. It was promoted in literature and it appears as a note on my bill. I have claiming it for about 20 years and I can confirm that it is correct they won't retrospectively apply it. Legally you have no chance.
I was in error in describing it as foul water as opposed to surface water. My mistake there. And in reply to buildersmate, the water company has admitted to knowing that the surface water was not going into the sewers, but are claiming it is the owner/tenants responsibility to clarify/query this. To me they are culpable by charging for a service they wilfully know they are not providing.
Interesting that you say they admit knowing. I wonder if they have done that in writing. I had been told by my water company that the default position was always that the company could not know unless informed by the customer. An exception to that could be for a newly connected house into the sewage system, in which the water company are of course involved in the connection. Your claim of twenty year predates the introduction of the discount.
It occurs to me that if this is just for surface water I'm surprised the companies are daft enough to offer a discount anyway. Most of the cost would surely be fixed, maintaining the pipes that have to be there anyway, so whether surface water goes down them or not, I would have thought would be a fairly minor extra expense for them.
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.