They might do that if it were an office cuck-up and they were trying to keep it in-office
I was asked to sit in on a neighbour - at an interview at home
and she blasted off with - right you have been overpaid as a result of statements you have made, and we want you to start repayment at £25
and I completely incredulous said
Can we see the papers on this ? you were looking at them 10 seconds ago
and she said no - data protection !
and I said yes data protection - they are his data....
and then I said I require you to identify yourself and the office you have comefrom...
and she said - if you do not state you are going to appeal, the deductions sstart immediately