Hi there cameo.
When my now 17yr old was around 15 she began asking to have her bottom lip pierced. Having piercings myself I didn't want to just give her a blanket NO so I asked her to go and think long and hard about why she wanted it done, was it because of a trend or did she genuinely want it for herself?
After a while she came back to me saying that it definately wasn't because others had had it done but because she really, really wanted it.
What my hubby and I then did with her was negotiate a "cooling off" period on the basis that if, after having to wait a few months and at least until she was 16, she still wanted it done then she would continue to do so, and if it were merely a 'phase' thing then the novelty would have, by then, worn off.
She also had to agree to either myself or my hubby taking her to have it done by a reputable body piercer and not just by some random shop assistant with a piercing gun.
All of our stipulations were met and after having her lip done she has gone on to have quite a few more. I wont list them all in case I scare you lol but she hasn't regretted having any of them done and still wants more.
Your daughter should be commended for asking your permission and then not going against your wishes. I'm sure we all know kids who would have had it done anyway then dealt with the fallout afterwards. I also think you might want to consider her offer of 'being good' til xmas - at least that gives you all a few weeks to think about it and if she wants it badly enough then she'll put in the effort.
Like ummmm I think having her ear done is the better option. That way its not too obvious, its easily hidden and if she changes her mind afterwards she can remove the ring and no one need ever know.
=0) twaflooers.