As far as I can recall, in my 60-odd years on this planet, I've never made or received any home-made food gift.
However, if someone is offering, anything with ginger in it would be very welcome. (e.g. ginger preserve, ginger cookies, gingerbread men, ginger ice cream, etc).
My neighbour makes wonderful chocolates every year for people. She also makes marzipan fruits which I LURVE. Marzipan is a love/hate item.. I fall into the former camp.... to which my expanding waistline will testify.
yes I would be delighted to know someone thought that much of me. would feel the same if I received home made cards. it means they have not only given their time but also thought and effort - part of them. a very generous gift.
I'm with Chris..anything ginger..chutney..jam..fudge..tablet...cake...same with hand made cards...it demonstrates real friendship and thoughtfulness...
I would always appreciate a homemade gift, whether it be food or otherwise. Especially popular in our house would be savoury relishes and chutneys. Whole grain mustards and horseradish sauces, delicious.