Can Someone Help Finish This Silly Argument

[pincurlpolkadot]

two of my friends have been arguing and we are trying to finish it and was wondering if anyone can help

ok ill start at the beginning two of my friends one is from America and the other is from Scotland and they was both talking about where they was brought up and apparently they both have similar up bringing's and lives they where both brought up in the country side they both live on farms and they are both very outdoorsy so anyway they was both like yay we have so much in common Best friend!! and all that, but then ana (the one from Scotland) mentioned something about them both being country girls and jen (the American one) said ana was wrong and said that you have to be American to be a country girl anyway ana said no you don't and jen said yes you do and ana said no you don't etc. and basically they both think they are right, (tbh Im on anas side and think she is right because they both live the same way and are practically the same person but with different accents and they are both obviously country girls, so me and my friend keith are trying to put a end to this argument so if anyone can help that would be great please share your thoughts and ill show them the posts and put a end to this silly argument (very childish I know haha)

[maggiebee]

Yes, you said it - very childish. Time to get a life methinks!

[mazie]

Unusual spelling of the name Ana...Is she Jewish?

[Prudie]

Is this serious? Why on earth would the American one say only an American can be a country girl? It's like saying only an American be a townie or city dweller.

[cassa333]

Typical American.

They think they invented everything and living in the country is obviously one of those inventions. Or should that be re-inventions?

Is the American confused with country music and coming from the country?

[pincurlpolkadot]

no shes called anabelle ana for short shes English just how its spelt and yes I just said its childish please just answer so we can get this crap over with

[Mamyalynne]

Country

Definition

districts and small settlements outside large urban areas or the capital.
"the airfield is right out in the country"
synonyms: countryside, green belt, great outdoors.


Girl

Definition

noun
1.
a female child.
"girls go through puberty earlier than boys"
synonyms: female child; More
a person's daughter.
"he was devoted to his little girl"
synonyms: female child; More
2.
a young or relatively young woman.
"I haven't got the time to meet girls"
synonyms: young woman, young lady, miss.


If they fit those definitions, argument over.

[pincurlpolkadot]

thanks prudie and cassa great answers I will show them or will have to get keith to bang there head together hahaha

[2sp_]

Ana is correct.

(By the way, you are either Scottish OR English. They are two different things. Like American or Canadian.)

[shoota]

Ana is right, Jen is wrong.
(Although I understand why Jen thinks she's right.)

[pincurlpolkadot]

thanks 2sp and I meant to say Scottish (im from England that why i said it got mixed up)

[Gizmonster]

So only an American, can officially be a country girl ?? Typical yank, thinking they own the world.
A country girl is a girl from the country .... does it matter which part of the world you're from ??? Does it f*** !!!

[jomifl]

It's a cultural thang

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=6aO3K64deNo

[pincurlpolkadot]

thanks gizmonster your absolutely right

[anneasquith]

id like to know a) what keith thinks, b) where does keith stay, c) do you know Scotland is not in England. ?

[Mamyalynne]

c) answered above ^^

[grasscarp]

Are either of your friends over the age of ten? If they are they dont have much going on in their lives if they can get hung up on such trivial stuff.

[pincurlpolkadot]

thanks mamyalynne haha think they was trying to sound clever ,got over exited and didn't read the rest of the posts haha bless um

[jno]

they're both country girls - it means countryside, not country as on a map.

[pincurlpolkadot]

has i have stated (twice) grasscarp they are being very childish but who doesn't now and again just trying to get this over with cause its getting very boring now lol

[boxtops]

That's it then, all finished. They are both country girls. You can be a country girl in any part of the world, America didn't invent it.