News0 min ago
unarrowed it down some more
43 Answers
I've just found out that bangor do ocean science aswell . . . I'm back up to 11 courses . . . Whats the best approach to narrowing down uni choices?
Perhaps write them in order of best to worst in several different aspects . . .
Perhaps write them in order of best to worst in several different aspects . . .
Answers
Best Answer
No best answer has yet been selected by mollykins. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.
For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.Molly, the best way IMO would be for you to weight all the different aspects. We do this with contracts - the bidders reply, we've already decided which items are vital (scores 5), desirable (scores 3), nice options (scores 1). (That's putting it very simply).
You then look at all the bids (i.e. in your case, what each uni can offer against ALL the headings, course, accommodation, ease of travel back home, all your criteria) and mark across, on a separate set of numbers - 3 if it meets your requirements, 4 or 5 if it's over your requirements, 1 or 2 if it doesn't. Multiply the Uni score against the weighting and you get a score for that Uni, which you can match against the scores of the others. If you are doing this on Excel it's a doddle.
List your criteria down the side in col 1 - weighting in col 2. The Unis going along the top in the remaining columns, 2 per Uni. Cols 3 + 4 are for the first uni - col has their score (1-5) then in col 4 you multiply cols 2x3 (weighting x score) to give a result for that criterion. When you've done, run a total of col 4 for the overall score. Repeat for the remaining unis, compare the totals. You will see which ones score highest, very clearly.
You then look at all the bids (i.e. in your case, what each uni can offer against ALL the headings, course, accommodation, ease of travel back home, all your criteria) and mark across, on a separate set of numbers - 3 if it meets your requirements, 4 or 5 if it's over your requirements, 1 or 2 if it doesn't. Multiply the Uni score against the weighting and you get a score for that Uni, which you can match against the scores of the others. If you are doing this on Excel it's a doddle.
List your criteria down the side in col 1 - weighting in col 2. The Unis going along the top in the remaining columns, 2 per Uni. Cols 3 + 4 are for the first uni - col has their score (1-5) then in col 4 you multiply cols 2x3 (weighting x score) to give a result for that criterion. When you've done, run a total of col 4 for the overall score. Repeat for the remaining unis, compare the totals. You will see which ones score highest, very clearly.
Boxtops is right - you can keep this simple by defining and weighting key categories like academic course, lecturer quality, research, Job search, sports, accommodation options, etc etc.....or make it more complex by a matrix where you define and weight key categories like academics, accommodation, social, university brand, graduate services and then break out and weight each category - say academics, course content, course research projects, lecturer reputation, exams vs continual assessment, academic facilities, turorial/personal coaching..........do this for each category and arrive at a sub category score and then add up the top level weighting. Again with excel a real doddle. - Could sell it to fellow candidate studs perhaps....
It's highly unlikey that you will be able to visit 11 different colleges/universities as they usually hold their open days on Wednesday (unless this has changed) and even if they are on different days you cannot justify missing over two weeks of school. You need to narrow them back down to the ones that are offering places which match your predicted grades. Then you should have a manageable short list.
Sherrard a couple nearby are on different wednesdays and I can go to weekend ones for the rest and portsmouth and southampton have one on a friday then the other the saturday so I'll only miss a couple of days in total. I think we're only allowed 3 or 4 days off to go to them else it's unauthorised absence . . .
Thank you pipin, interesting that molly comments on sherrard's thread but not on my and DT's offerings of the "best approach" which she moaned that noone was giving her. I used this model of evaluation and it works - but hey ho, no surprise, molly doesn't actually want practical viable suggestions. Yeah but no but...
Related Questions
Sorry, we can't find any related questions. Try using the search bar at the top of the page to search for some keywords, or choose a topic and submit your own question.