Should Boxing, As A Sport, Be Banned?

naomi24 | 10:57 Wed 07th Aug 2024 | Society & Culture

28 Answers

Khandro said elsewhere //The great Henry Cooper ran a boxing club for youngsters in the East End & he said, say what you like about boxing, but none of these lads are to be found on the streets mugging old ladies. //

Kids who play football or do gymnastics aren't to be found on the streets mugging old ladies either so that's not valid a defence specific to a sport that has opponents bashing seven bells out of one another.

So, is it brutal, is it barbaric, and should it be banned?

Employment

Brave Honest Man

Answers

1 to 20 of 28

1 2 Next Last

Best Answer

No best answer has yet been selected by naomi24. Once a best answer has been selected, it will be shown here.

For more on marking an answer as the "Best Answer", please visit our FAQ.

-- answer removed --

jourdain2

I dislike boxing intensly and hate to see women doing it. It strikes me as both brutal and barbaric. However, I was about to make the same point that Khandro did.

I can vouch from experience that it can be a means by which violent children can learn to control and direct their aggression, however. I'm thinking of one lad in particular who would definitely have 'gone very bad' without it, so I swallow my dislike and will not call for it to be banned.

ToraToraTora

Banning it will just drive it underground and unregulated.

seekeerz

It is a very violent sport and I feel today there is enough violence in the world without contributing to it, perhaps it's time to stop.

davebro3

10ClarionSt

In answer to the OP, yes, it should be banned.

I don't know why the first answer was removed but it seems to me that people enjoy teaching youngsters how to knock each others brains out, and then try to justify it by saying it keeps them off the streets. So knock each other senseless in the gym then, rather than outside.

And as for UFC, I believe that if the ref didn't dive in and stop the fights, the fighter would carry on beating the life out of their opponent until they were literally dead. I firmly believe that.

Also Manchester City Council tripped themselves up in 2002 when they realized they would have to stage the boxing tournament as part of the Commonwealth Games calender. Boxing is something that MCC are very much opposed to.

10ClarionSt

It's underground now. There's plenty of videos on YT of unlicensed boxing. I once went to a bare knuckle tournament in Salford. It'll always be there but won't get the publicity that it gets now.

naomi24

Question Author

//I don't know why the first answer was removed//

I posted in the wrong thread so removed it.

barry1010

No, I'm in favour of boxing, it instills self-discipline, self control and is excellent exercise.

Mozz71

Surprisingly, I agree with Tora. Drive it underground by banning it and it becomes unregulated and way more dangerous. Our 'Enry was right. Boxing gives a lot of disillusioned young people an outlet for their aggression. Better to get them in the ring than in the dock.

-- answer removed --

Hymie

Given that there is a great potential for injury (through boxing), maybe they should investigate changing the glove material/size to reduce the impact force (larger soft foam-filled gloves). Whilst a knockout punch would be much less likely, boxers would still score by landing punches on their opponent.

Khandro

I can't see a problem, - it's all entirely voluntary. Personally I would prefer judo, but that's probably because I've practiced it and know something about it.

There are rules to boxing, judges score points; it isn't just a matter of slugging your opponent to pulp, but that's how it may look to you naomi. 🙂

-- answer removed --

Old_Geezer

Boxing or no boxing, old ladies ought not be mugged.

I'm loathe to support a ban even though I can see why some call for it. Much better that folk get educated not to want to be violent and so voluntarily don't get involved.